I want to implement an incremental load process using SQL Server Change Data Capture. Every example I find takes the "happy path."
In other words, they assume that the CDC history exceeds the time since the last successful incremental load.
Suppose we leave the cleanup job with the default of 3 days, and for some reason our load hasn't successfully completed for longer than that. I need to check for this and run a full extract instead.
I'm logging the successful execution datetime in SQL Server tables. So, if I compare the last successful date to the earliest record in the cdc.lsn_time_mapping table, will this accomplish my task?
Basically something like:
Select #LastSuccessfulDate from audit....
Select #MinCdCDate = min(tran_begin_time) from cdc.lsn_time_mapping
if #MinCdCDate > #LastSuccessfulDate then 'Full' else 'Incremental'
Should this work? Is there a better way to accomplish it?
I would always stay in the "log domain" not the "time domain" when working directly with CDC. So track the last LSN of the last run and compare it against sys.fn_cdc_get_min_lsn every time you syncronize.
So if you last synchronized at lsn=100, and the min_lsn=110, then you've got a gap of 10 missing log records.
But this is only one of many scenarios that will require you to reinitialize the replication with a full sync, so you should also have an input parameter or somesuch to force a full sync.
Related
I've got a CSV file that refreshes every 60 seconds with live data from the internet. I want to automatically update my Access database (on a 60 second or so interval) with the new rows that get downloaded, however I can't simply link the DB to the CSV.
The CSV comes with exactly 365 days of data, so when another day ticks over, a day of data drops off. If i was to link to the CSV my DB would only ever have those 365 days of data, whereas i want to append the existing database with the new data added.
Any help with this would be appreciated.
Thanks.
As per the comments the first step is to link your CSV to the database. Not as your main table but as a secondary table that will be used to update your main table.
Once you do that you have two problems to solve:
Identify the new records
I assume there is a way to do so by timestamp or ID, so all you have to do is hold on to the last ID or timestamp imported (that will require an additional mini-table to hold the value persistently).
Make it happen every 60 seconds. To get that update on a regular interval you have two options:
A form's 'OnTimer' event is the easy way but requires very specific conditions. You have to make sure the form that triggers the event is only open once. This is possible even in a multi-user environment with some smart tracking.
If having an Access form open to do the updating is not workable, then you have to work with Windows scheduled tasks. You can set up an Access Macro to run as a Windows scheduled task.
Let's say I have a table with a date column; can I attach some sort of "watcher" that can take action if the date gets smaller than getdate()? Note that the date is larger than getdate() at the time of insertion.
Are there any tools that I might be unaware of in SQL Server 2008/2012?
Or would the best option be to poll the data from another application?
Edit: Note that there is no insertion/update taking place.
You could set up a SQL Job which runs periodically and executes a stored procedure which can then handle the logic around past dates.
https://msdn.microsoft.com/en-gb/library/ms187910.aspx
For example a SQL Job could be set up to run once daily to find out user's birthdays and send out an automated email.
In your case a job could be set up every minute (if required) which detects past dates and does something with those records. I would suggest adding some kind of flag to each record so that it isn't actioned the next time the job runs.
Alternatively if you have a lot of servers and databases, you could centralise your job scheduling using a third-party tool such as ActiveBatch.
I have data to load where I only need to pull records since the last time I pulled this data. There are no date fields to save this information in my destination table so I have to keep track of the maximum date that I last pulled. The problem is I can't see how to save this value in SSIS for the next time the project runs.
I saw this:
Persist a variable value in SSIS package
but it doesn't work for me because there is another process that purges and reloads the data separate from my process. This means that I have to do more than just know the last time my process ran.
The only solution I can think of is to create a table but it seems a bit much to create a table to hold one field.
This is a very common thing to do. You create an execution table that stores the package name, the start time, the end time, and whether or not the package failed/succeeded. You are then able to pull the max start time of the last successfully ran execution.
You can't persist anything in a package between executions.
What you're talking about is a form of differential replication and this has been done many many times.
For differential replication it is normal to store some kind of state in the subscriber (the system reading the data) or the publisher (the system providing the data) that remembers what state you're up to.
So I suggest you:
Read up on differential replication design patterns
Absolutely put your mind at rest about writing data to a table
If you end up having more than one source system or more than one source table your storage table is not going to have just one record. Have a think about that. I answered a question like this the other day - you'll find over time that you're going to add handy things like the last time the replication ran, how long it took, how many records were transferred etc.
Is it viable to have a SQL table with only one row and one column?
TTeeple and Nick.McDermaid are absolutely correct, and you should follow their advice if humanly possible.
But if for some reason you don't have access to write to an execution table, you can always use a script task to read/write the last loaded date to a text file on on whatever local file-system you're running SSIS on.
I haven't been able to find documentation/an explanation on how you would reload incremental data using Change Data Capture (CDC) in SQL Server 2014 with SSIS.
Basically, on a given day, if your SSIS incremental processing fails and you need to start again. How do you stage the recently changed records again?
I suppose it depends on what you're doing with the data, eh? :) In the general case, though, you can break it down into three cases:
Insert - check if the row is there. If it is, skip it. If not, insert it.
Delete - assuming that you don't reuse primary keys, just run the delete again. It will either find a row to delete or it won't, but the net result is that the row with that PK won't exist after the delete.
Update - kind of like the delete scenario. If you reprocess an update, it's not really a big deal (assuming that your CDC process is the only thing keeping things up to date at the destination and there's no danger of overwriting someone/something else's changes).
Assuming you are using the new CDC SSIS 2012 components, specifically the CDC Control Task at the beginning and end of the package. Then if the package fails for any reason before it runs the CDC Control Task at the end of the package those LSNs (Log Sequence Number) will NOT be marked as processed so you can just restart the SSIS package from the top after fixing the issue and it will just reprocess those records again. You MUST use the CDC Control Task to make this work though or keep track the LSNs yourself (before SSIS 2012 this was the only way to do it).
Matt Masson (Sr. Program Manager on MSFT SQL Server team) has a great post on this with a step-by-step walkthrough: CDC in SSIS for SQL Server 2012
Also, see Bradley Schacht's post: Understanding the CDC state Value
So I did figure out how to do this in SSIS.
I record the min and max LSN number everytime my SSIS package runs in a table in my data warehouse.
If I want to reload a set of data from the CDC source to staging, in the SSIS package I need to use the CDC Control Task and set it to "Mark CDC Start" and in the text box labelled "SQL Server LSN to start...." I put the LSN value I want to use as a starting point.
I haven't figured out how to set the end point, but I can go into my staging table and delete any data with an LSN value > then my endpoint.
You can only do this for CDC changes that have not been 'cleaned up' - so only for data that has been changed within the last 3 days.
As a side point, I also bring across the lsn_time_mapping table to my data warehouse since I find this information historically useful and it gets 'cleaned up' every 4 days in the source database.
To reload the same changes you can use the following methods.
Method #1: Store the TFEND marker from the [cdc_states] table in another table or variable. Reload back the marker to your [cdc_states] from the "saved" value to process the same range again. This method, however, allows you to start processing from the same LSN but if in the meanwhile you change table got more changes those changes will be captured as well. So, you can potentially get more changes that happened after you did the first data capture.
Method #2: In order to capture the specified range, record the TFEND markers before and after the range is processed. Now, you can use the OLEDB Source Connection (SSIS) with the following cdc functions. Then use the CDC Splitter as usual to direct Inserts, Updates, and Deletes.
DECLARE #start_lsn binary(10);
DECLARE #end_lsn binary(10);
SET #start_lsn = 0x004EE38E921A01000001;-- TFEND (1) -- if null then sys.fn_cdc_get_min_lsn('YourCapture') to start from the beginnig of _CT table
SET #end_lsn = 0x004EE38EE3BB01000001; -- TFEND (2)
SELECT * FROM [cdc].[fn_cdc_get_net_changes_YOURTABLECAPTURE](
#start_lsn
,#end_lsn
,N'all' -- { all | all with mask | all with merge }
--,N'all with mask' -- shows values in "__$update_mask" column
--,N'all with merge' -- merges inserts and updates together. It's meant for processing the results using T-SQL MERGE statement
)
ORDER BY __$start_lsn;
I'm a beginner with SQL Server. For a project I need CDC to be turned on. I copy the cdc data to another (archive) database and after that the CDC tables can be cleaned immediately. So the retention time doesn't need to be high, I just put it on 1 minute and when the cleanup job runs (after the retention time is already fulfilled) it appears that it only deleted a few records (the oldest ones). Why didn't it delete everything? Sometimes it doesn't delete anything at all. After running the job a few times, the other records get deleted. I find this strange because the retention time has long passed.
I set the retention time at 1 minute (I actually wanted 0 but it was not possible) and didn't change the threshold (= 5000). I disabled the schedule since I want the cleanup job to run immediately after the CDC records are copied to my archive database and not particularly on a certain time.
My logic for this idea was that for example there will be updates in the afternoon. The task to copy CDC records to archive database should run at 2:00 AM, after this task the cleanup job gets called. So because of the minimum retention time, all the CDC records should be removed by the cleanup job. The retention time has passed after all?
I just tried to see what happened when I set up a schedule again in the job, like how CDC is meant to be used in general. After the time has passed I checked the CDC table and turns out it also only deletes the oldest record. So what am I doing wrong?
I made a workaround where I made a new job with the task to delete all records in the CDC tables (and disabled the entire default CDC cleanup job). This works better as it removes everything but it's bothering me because I want to work with the original cleanup job and I think it should be able to work in the way that I want it to.
Thanks,
Kim
Rather than worrying about what's in the table, I'd use the helper functions that are created for each capture instance. Specifically, cdc.fn_cdc_get_all_changes_ and cdc.fn_cdc_get_net_changes_. A typical workflow that I've used wuth these goes something below (do this for all of the capture instances). First, you'll need a table to keep processing status. I use something like:
create table dbo.ProcessingStatus (
CaptureInstance sysname,
LSN numeric(25,0),
IsProcessed bit
)
create unique index [UQ_ProcessingStatus]
on dbo.ProcessingStatus (CaptureInstance)
where IsProcessed = 0
Get the current max log sequence number (LSN) using fn_cdc_get_max_lsn.
Get the last processed LSN and increment it using fn_cdc_increment_lsn. If you don't have one (i.e. this is the first time you've processed), use fn_cdc_get_min_lsn for this instance and use that (but don't increment it!). Record whatever LSN you're using in the table with, set IsProcessed = 0.
Select from whichever of the cdc.fn_cdc_get… functions makes sense for your scenario and process the results however you're going to process them.
Update IsProcessed = 1 for this run.
As for monitoring your original issue, just make sure that the data in the capture table is generally within the retention period. That is, if you set it to 2 days, I wouldn't even think about it being a problem until it got to be over 4 days (assuming that your call to the cleanup job is scheduled at something like every hour). And when you process with the above scheme, you don't need to worry about "too much" data being there; you're always processing a specific interval rather than "everything".