Some background
Our team has been using Material-UI (MUI) for quite some time, and we love it. With the release of MUI v5, we took the time to check which styling solution we would use next, since JSS is being abandoned by the MUI team.
We ended up following a discussion from the folks at Shopify. They made a very detailed comparison of styling solutions, and ended up with vanilla-extract as their tool of choice. Strong TypeScript support and, foremost, the zero-runtime-approach, got us convinced.
Sadly, vanilla-extract had not been considered by the MUI core team in their decision making.
Question at hand
MUI, according to their docs, enables the user to use various styling solutions. The styling engine used under the hood can be configured, as roughly described here.
Questions:
is it (conceptually) possible and (pragmatically) reasonable to use vanilla-extract for:
styling MUI components?
using it as the style engine underlying MUI?
where would sprinkles come into play?
what would be the concrete steps for implementing this approach?
has somebody done this already, and would be willing to share their code? đ
Contrary to common practice, I haven't really tried anything yet, implementation-wise. From my understanding, this would mean creating something along the lines of mui-styled-engine (wraps emotion) and mui-styled-engine-sc (wraps styled-components). Since that seemed pretty involved to me, I thought I'd ask first.
The detailed comparison you provided doesn't includes jss.
But you can use jss directly without a setup from MUI.
Use react-jss. I don't know about zero runtime thing but they also support typescript and will be easy for you to migrate your existing stylesheets written on MUI4. You just need to change the function names such as makeStyle to createUseStyles.
Here is the whole doc - https://cssinjs.org/react-jss/?v=v10.9.0
I personally like jss because it helps to keep styles intact from the actual components. I have use it over MUI 5 provided styled engines and really much happy with the results.
Related
I'm developing an app using react js. I just want to ask your opinion. Is it redundant to use MUI Component and React Bootstrap at the same time?
There's nothing stopping you from using both MUI and Bootstrap in your project but either one should be able to meet all your design requirements.
But in choosing both you would have to keep in mind two very different approaches to design. The MUI implementation varies quite a bit from React Bootstrap. Not sure what you are going for here, but in a very general sense I would stick with one for my project/purpose.
(Personally I prefer MUI)
I think both libraries are great, but generally the approach is to pick one to keep less dependencies in your package.json file. You have to keep single approach when it comes to styling for two reasons:
Consistency
Whoever reads your codebase will be able to comprehend easily.
P.S: I prefer MUI, you can customize your own design system by overriding MUI default theme
No, it's not redundant for your project. The amount of work that's been put into Material UI makes it a feasible choice for professional projects.
Also, if you are worried about libraries taking more bundle size then as per the Material UI documentation, you can reduce bundle size by importing your components in the following way: let's say you want the button component, so you import it like this import Button from '#material-ui/core/Button', instead of this import { Button } from '#material-ui/core'. With the former import you'll be importing the Button module only and leaving the rest of the modules alone. For further detail, visit this link: https://v3.material-ui.com/guides/minimizing-bundle-size/.
Hope you find this answer satisfactory!
Usually you pick one widgets library, but if you miss some components you can mix them too. According to mui documentation every component is self contained:
https://mui.com/material-ui/getting-started/usage/
If you are worried about inconsistencies in your widgets, mui now offers unstyled components as a standalone package:
https://mui.com/base/getting-started/overview/
For react-bootstrap the components can be customized in many ways, especially over global customization via sass variables:
https://react-bootstrap.github.io/getting-started/introduction/#installation
I wouldn't worry too much about dependencies as you usually have so many of them anyway and install new package for every use case.
In my current project for example I have react-bootstrap as the main UI-lib, but it has no date pickers nativly. So after a research I picked up the mui datepickers.
I am building my first react website, and i wanted to ask what the best practice is when it comes to styling. Does it make more sense to make a different stylesheet for each component or it makes more sense to have the styles for all components in a single stylesheet.
It is best practice to have a common style sheet - styles used between components. In addition, anything component specific I would have in it's own style sheet to avoid polluting your shared style sheet.
From the official docs:
React does not have an opinion about how styles are defined; if in doubt, a good starting point is to define your styles in a separate *.css file as usual and refer to them using className.
For a review of React styling methods, take a look at this (slightly older) presentation by Max Stoiber - Styling React.JS applications. It's a couple of years old but worth a look.
CSS-in-JS has been the most appealing to me. There are numerous techniques/packages, so here is a useful comparison.
I jumped into React recently, so I'm very confused about many things. One of them is about how most of people design UI in React.
Before jumping in, I used Bootstrap to design UI of my website by using pre-made components such as buttons, modal views, navigations, and so on. But, figured out I can't use it anymore in React, but I can use React-Bootstrap instead. Is React-Bootstrap still the most popular UI framework in React as well? I'm asking that because I found some other UI frameworks such as Semantic UI or Material UI for React.
Also, I found styled-components. However, styled-components makes me feel like I need to make every component by myself to use which sounds like taking too long time.
As a very beginner, I'm curious about how people usually work on UI in React?
Firstly, There is no clear answer for the problem. In general purpose of styled-components not mean don't use another ui framework. And the companies solve the problems which is spesific with their Engineering Team. They have their own architecture though. But the alone programmers are choose some open source solutions.
Well, Some people use together or alone. It's totally about your project or your style of architecture. But still i would say some stuffs for giving point of view.
In the other hand; the UI Frameworks are solve modular problems. An example: You cannot create a modal with only css even styled-components. you know, you need JavaScript for that.
To use both:
You can use on Elements Semantic-UI(ReactJS or direct element with the className),
You can use styled-components instead of css file for spesific part of your project. As e.g: Main, Aside, Article, Post, TopNavigation etc.
If you prefer to use the styled-components, also you can use same components in React Native. (There is no css file support for React Native. You'll need inline CSS)
To use only div instead of the spesific component, you'll confused after project being bigger. I would recommended you to create for each meaningful Element.
You can combine the open source community UI parts with your own CSS.
You won't need a CSS(Less, Sass) file when you use styled-components. That's mean, you'll work only on your JS files instead CSS files, so you can do dynamic things in your components. styled-components supports almost all CSS features.
To use standalone Semantic-UI:
I prefer Semantic-UI-React instead of ReactJS bootstrap frameworks.
You cannot use the CSS of Semantic-UI-React in React Native. You should choose which is another solution or actually make your own your components architecture.
You are ready to go with every project with Semantic-UI-React for web/mobile site.
You have to learn basics of less-lang.
You can change everything from your theme files which variables.
Lastly,
If you have big project or goal though; nevertheless, i think you should use a UI Framework in learning and adaptive process.
If you are still not sure what you should do you then, you have to try all of them to find your own architecture.
I think in learning process, you have to concern about ReactJS needs(Redux, Router etc.) before CSS.
It's my first answer at Stackoverflow. Hopefully, the answer will help you for your concern.
I just started learning ReactXP and I want to use React-Navigation-https://reactnavigation.org/ in ReactXP. Is React-Navigation is supported in ReactXP? If yes, Then we have any working example?
I found one example but its not working. https://github.com/LeJPR/reactxp-navigation-example
Referring to this link (https://microsoft.github.io/reactxp/docs/extensions/navigator.html) the default way of reactXP is currently not using React-Navigation but might do in the future.
The current implementation of Navigator on React Native makes use of the deprecated âNavigator Experimentalâ. We will look at moving away from this implementation to the now-recommended âreact-navigationâ in the near future. Some of the more advanced interfaces may need to change. These are listed at the end of this article. Use these with caution.
I read somewhere in the reactXP issue list on gitHub that your example (https://github.com/LeJPR/reactxp-navigation-example) does not just use react-navigation but had to change the annimation system used in reactXP and seems to not beeing updated anymore.
The core of react-navigation works fine with reactxp, to get it running as is you just need to create reactxp versions of the views used by the different navigator types such as stack/drawer/tab. In doing this though i ran into some challenges with the parity of reactxp animation vs react-native. Unless i'm mistaken it seems there's some quite fundamental limitations with reactxp animation currently - from what i can see you can only have a single interpolation off an animated value (add another and it will overwrite the first), only two values in an interpolation array (as opposed to multiple steps). This functionality is used extensively in the react-navigation views for native like experience. To get around this (driven by a lack of time to consider how to reimplement with reactxp animation) i ended up patching in animatedjs for use on reactxp web navigation views, which provides parity with react-native. Kind of leads me to believe considering animation might be a precursor to react-navigation/more important question. Happy to put up a sample of the above approach to getting react-navigation working with reactxp if of benefit - definitely just for awareness and not production use though!
The example does actually come from this reactXP issue: https://github.com/Microsoft/reactxp/issues/9#issuecomment-303717309
Options I found for Navigation without writing an Extention on your own
contained in reactXP https://microsoft.github.io/reactxp/docs/extensions/navigator.html
also from reactXP team but not in use? https://github.com/Microsoft/react-native-experimental-navigation
an other navigation package I found https://github.com/ymzuiku/react-router-hash-history
I'm pretty new to development. Right now working on an webapp in my freetime.
Backend will be written in Python (here I have the best experience).
How good is the Idea to mixing React components:
like: https://github.com/brillout/awesome-react-components
My Idea was to use these components or let others create components for me (for example a slide show or whatever)
The question is, is this a good Idea? I'm worry that this might create a lot of overhead. For example one component is based on bootstrap and the other on foundation (As I said I'm not experienced web developer and can't judge if this can actualy really happen).
Thanks!
The idea of React components is to have the smallest piece of code you can define.
However, mixing different CSS frameworks, like Bootstrap or Foundation doesn't sound like the best idea. You can, of course mix ready-made components (like React-Bootstrap) with your own custom components, but ideally you would choose one framework and stick with it.
The good thing about React is that you can possibly switch between Frameworks without the need of refactoring everything.
Let's say, for instance, you have a custom component called Slider. If you later decide to use MaterialUI, depending on your configurations, you could just change the import from import Slider from "./Slider" to import Slider from "material-ui/Slider" and the rest of your code would be untouched.
Pick a CSS / UI framework and stick with it. These days I have been working with Semantic UI and they have good integration with React via http://react.semantic-ui.com/
It is awesome! :)
And in addition to that, you can also build your own custom components.
If you think adding a whole framework to your project is a lot of burden, then you can make everything your own from scratch. (Either (1) using the CSS framework classes for the components or (2) defining your own CSS classes)
And to conclude I also agree to not mix CSS frameworks as there might be conflicts! It's not fun! In my project, Bootstrap was conflicting with Semantic UI, so I just stuck with the latter.