What empty binary files contain in C - c

Question

#include <stdio.h>
#include <stdlib.h>
int main(void) {
FILE *fp;
fp = fopen("clients.dat", "wb");
fclose(fp);
fp = fopen("clients.dat", "rb");
while (1) {
if (fp == EOF)
break;
else
printf("There is something inside a file");
}
fclose(fp);
return 0;
}
Here comes a question: what do empty binary files contain? should the pointer point to the EOF character? I mean: isn't it that the first and last thing in the file is EOF? OR how Can I check whether a file is empty or not?

Answer 1

An empty file contains nothing, it is empty. So it contains 0 bytes. EOF is not a character that is at the end of a file, it is an integer constant used as return value from some of the standard methods reading from a file to indicate end of file or some sort of error.
When you open a file you get a pointer to a FILE type back, this is what you can expect even from an empty file.
A file is not terminated the same way a string is, so there is no equivalent of a NULL character in a file, that determines when the file contents stops.
To determine whether a file you have opened and have a valid FILE pointer to is empty you can use fseek and ftell:
fseek(fp, 0, SEEK_END);
size = ftell(fp);
if (size == 0) {
// File is empty
}

Answer 2

Function fopen returns a pointer to a file handle of type FILE, not a pointer to any content of the file or a pointer to an EOF-character. The pointer is NULL if the file could not be opened at all, but does not indicate whether the file is empty or not.
To check if a file is empty you either (1) need to make an attempt to read bytes and handle the various results, or (2) to use fseek and ftell to move the read pointer to the end and ask then for the position.
(1)
fp=fopen("clients.dat","rb");
char buffer;
size_t bytesRead = fread(&buffer, 1, 1, fp); // try to read one byte
if(bytesRead == 1) {
printf("file contains at least one byte\n");
} else { // error handling
if (feof(fp))
printf("Attemt to read though end of file has been reached. File is empty.\n");
else if (ferror(fp)) {
perror("Error reading file.");
}
}
(2)
fp=fopen("clients.dat","rb");
fseek(fp, 0L, SEEK_END);
long size = ftell(fp);
if (size==0) {
// file is empty.
}
I'd prefer the second variant.

Answer 3

Here's another approach:
To check if the file is empty, you can simply read the file:
int c = fgetc(fp);
if (c == EOF)
{
// The file is empty or an error occured
if (feof(fp))
{
// Empty
}
else
{
// Error during file read
}
}
else
{
// non-empty file
}

Answer 4

Here comes a question what empty binary files contain ?
Empty files contain nothing, that is what makes them empty.
Regular files have a size which is not part of their data, but instead is normally a part of the directory entry or inode.
should the pointer point to the EOF character ?
No
First of all the pointer returned by fopen is NOT a pointer to the content of the file, but merely a pointer to a data structure describing the open file.
Secondly EOF is not an actual part of the file, but a special return value from the getc family of functions used to indicate that the end of file has been reached.
To test whether you are at the end of a file without reading from it you can use the feof function.