write Error: Broken Pipe in C using execlp - c

Question

I have issues creating simple C program which takes arguments from command line, the last argument is path to the file. Program runs cat command on given file, and then runs tr on the result of cat. Tr gets arguments from command line(other than the last argument). I am getting errors:
Missing operand.
write error: Broken Pipe.
I am not sure where the mistake is...
#include <unistd.h>
#include <stdio.h>
#include <stdlib.h>
#include <string.h>
#define WRITE_END 1
#define READ_END 0
int main(int argc, char* argv[]){
if(argc < 2){
printf("\nPROVIDE AN ARGUMENT\n");
return 1;
}
const char * file = argv[argc - 1];
char ** args = calloc(argc - 2, sizeof(char*));
for( int i = 1; i<argc-2; i++){
args[i - 1 ] = argv[i];
}
int fd[2];
pipe(fd);
pid_t child;
if((child = fork()) == -1)return 2;
if(child == 0){
dup2(fd[WRITE_END], STDOUT_FILENO);
close(fd[READ_END]);
close(fd[WRITE_END]);
execlp("cat", "cat", file, (char*)NULL);
exit(1);
}
else{
dup2(fd[READ_END], STDIN_FILENO);
close(fd[WRITE_END]);
close(fd[READ_END]);
execlp("tr", "tr", *args, (char*)NULL);
exit(1);
}
close(fd[0]);
close(fd[1]);
wait(0);
wait(0);
return 0;
}

Answer 1

There are a few problems here that are keeping you from getting this to work. First, as mentioned by Nate Eldredge in a comment, there are problems with the allocation and copying of the all-but-last arguments to variable args. Second, your use of execlp has a slight problem in that the arguments should include an extra argument corresponding to the name of the program run (not the same as the file opened as the executable, lots of people get confused about this point). Third, as also mentioned by Nate, you need to call execvp in the branch of the if-else corresponding to the parent process (the "else" branch). Its second argument will need to be an array of pointers to character, the last of which is NULL.
So taking these one at a time. First, you need to allocate argc slots for args to use it in something like the way you intend:
char ** args = calloc(argc, sizeof(char*));
memcpy(args, argv, sizeof(char*)*(argc -1));
The first line allocates an array of character pointers the same size as the arg. list. The second line copies all but the last pointer in argv to the corresponding location in args and leaves the last one as NULL (calloc initialized the storage for it to be zero, and you need the last pointer in args to be a null pointer if you're going to pass it to execvp, which you will). Note that you're not duplicating all of the storage under argv, just the pointers in the first dimension (remember: argv[0] is a pointer and argv[0][0] is the first character in the program name).
Note that your use of close and dup was fine. I don't know why anyone objected to that unless they forgot that allocating a file descriptor always takes the lowest-numbered descriptor that is unused. That's about the most important thing about descriptor tables as originally used in UNIX.
Next, the call to execlp that overlays the child process created by fork with "cat" is missing an argument. It should be:
execlp("cat", "cat", file, (char*)NULL);
That extra "cat" in there is the value cat will receive when it enters main() as argv[0]. You're probably noticing that this looks like you could lie about the name of the program you're running with the exec__ functions, and you can (but you can't completely hide having done it).
Finally, that second execlp call. You can't pass arguments through as if they were typed on the command line, in one big string: exec in any form doesn't use a shell to invoke the other program and it's not going to parse the command line for you. In addition, the way you were (apparently, if I've read your intent correctly) trying to concatenate the argument strings was also not right (see above comments about args allocation and the memcpy call). You have to break out individual arguments and pass them to it. So if you have an array of pointer to character and the last one is NULL, like you'll have in args after the changes I indicated for allocating and copying data, then you can just pass args to execvp:
execvp("tr", args);
These aren't huge errors and a lot of people make these kinds of mistakes when starting out with manipulating the argument list and using the fork and exec functions. A lot of people make mistakes trying to use a pipe between parent and child processes but you seem to have gotten that part right.
One last thing: the lines downstream in execution from the exec__ calls only get executed if there's an error performing the actual replacement of the running program with the new one. Errors on the command line of "cat" or "tr", for example, won't cause exec__ to fail. Errors like lack of permission to execute the file given as the first argument or absence of the file will cause the exec__ functions to fail. Unless exec returns an error, nothing downstream of the exec call is executed in the process in which it is executed (a successful exec never returns).