Error 424 when trying to delete element in array vba [duplicate] - arrays

Question

This question already has an answer here:
Search for an element in the VBA ArrayList
(1 answer)
Closed 2 years ago.
I was trying to delete the specific element in the array vba when certain condition are true but i end up getting error 424. May I know the right way to do it? I tired to use redim, however it doesn't suit my condition as after the comparing with others array i need to store the data back into excel file where the location in the excel file is already sorted.
Before changing the remarkRange to array variant, I used it as Dim remarkRange
As Range where I can just use .Clear to clear the range item in a specific element.
I tried remarkRange(I, 1)=" " it runs without error but im not sure if its suitable. May I know the correct way to do it? Thanks.
Dim remarkRange() As Variant
remarkRange= wb.Sheets("wb").Range("A1:A5").Value2
For I = LBound(remarkRange) To UBound(remarkRange)
If (some condition is true) then
remarkRange(I, 1).Delete
End If
Next I
I expected the element in the specific cell in the array to be empty, but I got error 424

Answer 1

An array doesn't have a Delete method. It's also misleading to have the Range in remarkRange when it's an array, not a Range. Maybe a different name, e.g. remarks or whatever is clear to you.
If you're going to write the array back to the worksheet, then I see no problem changing an element to a blank string.
For i = LBound(remarks, 1) To UBound(remarks, 1)
If some condition Then
remarks(i, 1) = ""
End If
Next i

Answer 2

It seems you'll need to decide what you mean by 'delete'. I'm not aware of a Delete property of an array of variants so while your code might compile it would throw an object required error.
However, your point about previously using the Clear method on a Range object, suggests that you just want to read your range values into an array, remove the contents if certain conditions aren't me, and then re-write your array to the range. If that's the case, you probably wouldn't want to resize your array as the rows or columns wouldn't line up - more commonly, you'd set the item of your variant array to Empty.
The code below shows how to do this in a simple routine of taking 10 numbers from column A, removing all odd numbers and re-writing the numbers to Column C - but with the rows still matching:
Public Sub EmptyItemsAndKeepArraySize()
Dim inArr() As Variant
Dim i As Long
'Read range into arrays.
inArr = Sheet1.Range("A1:A10").Value2
'Clear all numbers that are not even.
For i = 1 To UBound(inArr, 1)
If inArr(i, 1) Mod 2 <> 0 Then inArr(i, 1) = Empty
Next
'Write cleared array to column C
Sheet1.Range("c1").Resize(UBound(inArr, 1)).Value = inArr
End Sub
If, however, you really do want to remove and resize your array, then a simple way of doing it is to populate a temporary collection first, resizing an output array and then populating that with the collection items. In the example below the code removes all odd numbers and then writes the array to column B - but as an array reduced in size (ie contiguous rows):
Public Sub DeleteItemsAndShrinkArray()
Dim inArr() As Variant, outArr() As Variant
Dim i As Long
Dim temp As Collection
Dim v As Variant
'Read range into arrays.
inArr = Sheet1.Range("A1:A10").Value2
'Keep all even numbers in a temporary collection.
Set temp = New Collection
For i = 1 To UBound(inArr, 1)
If inArr(i, 1) Mod 2 = 0 Then temp.Add inArr(i, 1)
Next
'Dimension the output array.
ReDim outArr(1 To temp.Count, 1 To 1)
'Populate new array from temp collection.
i = 1
For Each v In temp
outArr(i, 1) = v
i = i + 1
Next
'Write reduced array to column B
Sheet1.Range("B1").Resize(UBound(outArr, 1)).Value = outArr
End Sub