Related
I would like to send callbacks with different signatures for the same function. Somenthing like this:
#include <stdio.h>
#include <stdarg.h>
void a(int pa) {}
void b(int pb1, float pb2) {}
// exec implementation
int main() {
exec(a, 1);
exec(b, 1, 2.3);
}
I thought of using something like:
void exec(void (*func)(...), ...) {
int arg1;
float arg2;
va_list valist;
va_start(valist, size);
arg1 = va_arg(valist, int);
if (size == 1) {
(*func)(arg1);
va_end(valist);
return;
}
arg2 = va_arg(valist, float);
if (size == 2) {
(*func)(arg1, arg2);
va_end(valist);
return;
}
}
But obviously it doesn't work :(
The usual solution to making callback function interfaces flexible with respect to data provided to the function is to give the callback signature a void * parameter (possibly in addition to other parameters). Arbitrary data can be provided via such a parameter. Something like this:
void exec(void (*func)(void *), void *data) {
func(data);
}
struct s2 {
int i;
float f;
};
void func1(void *data) {
int i = *(int *)data;
// ...
}
void func2(void *data) {
struct s2 s = *(struct s2 *)data;
// ...
}
int main(void) {
int i = 42;
struct s2 s = { .i = 17, .f = 3.14 };
exec(func1, &i);
exec(func2, &s);
}
HOWEVER, It is possible to do something more like you describe, where the callback functions genuinely have different signatures, by specifying the callback type without a prototype. In that case, there are still at least these caveats:
If the callback functions themselves are defined with prototypes (as they should be) then the parameter types should not be any that are altered by the default argument promotions. So, pointers, ints, doubles, but not floats or short ints or chars (not an exhaustive list). If you wanted to support other parameter types then you would need to cast the function pointer before calling the function, as described later.
The callback functions cannot be variadic.
If the front-end is variadic, then it needs to be told at runtime, somehow, what the actual number and types of the arguments are.
Furthermore, there will need to be explicit calls to the callback functions, with correct arguments, so there can be only a fixed set of predetermined callback signatures supported.
For example, that might look something like this:
enum sig { INT, INT_DOUB };
void exec(void (*func)(/* no prototype */), enum sig cb_sig, ...);
void a(int pa) {}
void b(int pb1, double pb2) {}
int main(void) {
exec(a, INT, 1);
exec(b, INT_DOUB, 1, 2.3);
}
void exec(void (*func)(/* no prototype */), enum sig cb_sig, ...) {
va_list valist;
va_start(valist, cb_sig);
switch (cb_sig) {
case INT: {
int i = va_arg(valist, int);
func(i);
break;
}
case INT_DOUB: {
int i = va_arg(valist, int);
double d = va_arg(valist, double);
func(i, d);
break;
}
default:
assert(("Can't be reached", 0));
}
va_end(valist);
}
It is possible that that would elicit a few warnings, such as about a function declaration that does not provide a prototype, and about calling a (declared, but) unprototyped function. Since you know the signatures by the time you execute the calls, however, you could get rid of the latter kind of warning via appropriate casting. For example,
// ...
case INT: {
int i = va_arg(valist, int);
((void (*)(int))func)(i);
break;
}
// ...
You could change the callbacks to take a single va_list argument:
void a(va_list args)
{
int pa = va_arg(args,int);
}
void b(va_list args)
{
int pb1 = va_arg(args,int);
double pb2 = va_arg(args,double);
}
And have your other function pass the va_list along.
void exec(void (*func)(va_list), ...)
{
va_list valist;
va_start(valist, func);
func(valist);
va_end(valist);
}
You can use va_args to solve this.
#include <stdio.h>
#include <stdint.h>
#include <stdarg.h>
#define exec_func(func, ...) func(__VA_ARGS__)
long func(char *a, int b, long c, long d)
{
printf("a: %s, b: %d, c: %ld, d: %ld\n", a, b, c, d);
return c + d;
}
int main()
{
printf("c + d: %ld\n", exec_func(func, "test", 10, 1000, 1000));
}
Previously I asked How to make a function which receive a function as param in C language. I get an answer Link to the question but this solution is based on the parameters of argument's function. I mean:
int functionToPassAsParameter (int arg1, int arg2){
// do something
}
int functionWhichReceiveFunction (int (*f)(), int arg1, int arg2){
// do something
f(arg1, arg2);
// do something
}
// How to call the function
functionWhichReceiveFunction (&functionToPassAsParameter, 1, 2);
I would like something like:
int functionToPassAsParameter (int arg1, int arg2){
// do something
}
int functionWhichReceiveFunction ( f() ){
// do something
f();
// do something
}
// How to call the function
functionWhichReceiveFunction ( functionToPassAsParameter(arg1, arg2) );
So, when I call the function, I pass the correctly params but when I define the function which receive the other function I do not specify which params I will send to it. Is that possible to make?
EDIT 1:
I wanna achieve pass any function to functionWhichReceiveFunction. Something like:
int function_a (int param1, int param2) { /* Do something */ };
void function_b (char *arg1) { /* Do something */ };
// Call the function with two differents functions regardless return type nor params
int x = functionWhichReceiveFunction ( function_a(param1, param2) );
functionWhichReceiveFunction ( function_b(arg1) );
Define the function to be passed to take a void * as a parameter. That way the function that calls the given function doesn't need to know anything specific about the parameters:
struct params1 {
int arg1;
int arg2;
};
struct params2 {
char *arg1;
char *arg2;
};
int functionToPassAsParameter (void *param){
struct params1 *args = params;
// do something
}
int otherFunctionToPassAsParameter (void *param){
struct params2 *args = params;
// do something
}
int functionWhichReceiveFunction (int (*f)(void *), void *args) {
// do something
f(args);
// do something
}
struct params1 p1 = { 1, 2 };
functionWhichReceiveFunction (&functionToPassAsParameter, &p1);
struct params2 p2 = { "abc", "def" };
functionWhichReceiveFunction (&otherFunctionToPassAsParameter, &p2);
To be able to pass a function with unknown parameters to a function, declare the function that will pass the function as follows:
int g(int (*f)());
The function that is actually passed can have any number of parametes, for example:
int f(int x, void *y);
The call is now as follows:
g(f);
The above means that g passes f, which can have zero or more parameters of any type. This is denoted by the empty parameter list.
A particular function that may need to be passed is for example f.
Now g is called with function f, or any other function.
Note that it is up to g to know which parameters must be passed in calling f. So you need a "protocol" that tells g which function/type is passed. For example, besides passing the function, pass an identifier (int) that says what type of function is passed, for example:
#define fS_I_I 1 // f needs String, int, Int
#define fD_I 2 // f needs Double, Int
#define fI_I 3 // f needs Int, Int
int g(int ID, int (*f)());
g(fI_I, f);
Learn more about closures and tagged unions. Notice that C don't have them. You might want to emulate that with callbacks
I wanna achieve pass any function to functionWhichReceiveFunction
You cannot do that simply and portably. Remember that the signature of a function in C is related to its calling conventions (so to the ABI used by your compiler and your code; for examples, look into Linux x86 ABIs; so floating point arguments could be passed in different registers as integral arguments, so your compiler needs to know the signature of all your function pointers). You need to also give to functionWhichReceiveFunction something which describes the signature.
What you might consider doing, assuming your platform have function pointers of the same size and in the same address space as data pointers (this is very often the case), is to pass to functionWhichReceiveFunction a void* pointer (actually, a function pointer casted to void*) and an enumeration describing it.
For example
enum funsig_en {
funsig_void_to_void,
funsig_int_to_void,
funsig_int_to_double,
funsig_int_double_to_void,
};
Then, you'll have corresponding function signatures (types)
typedef void fun_void_to_void(void);
typedef void fun_int_to_void(int);
typedef double fun_int_to_double(int);
typedef void fun_int_double_to_void(int, double);
Suppose you have these static functions
static void statf_void_to_void(void);
static void statf_int_to_void(int);
static double statf_int_to_double(int);
static void statf_int_double_to_void(int, double);
You might declare
void
functionWhichReceiveFunction (void*res, enum funsig_en sigkind, void*fun, ...);
and you could use it as
functionWhichRecieveFunction(NULL, funsig_void_to_void
(void*)statf_void_to_void);
or
functionWhichRecieveFunction(NULL, funsig_int_to_void,
(void*)statf_int_to_void, 123);
or
double r = 0;
functionWhichRecieveFunction(&r, funsig_int_to_double,
(void*)statf_int_to_double, 2345);
I leave you to code that variadic functionWhichRecieveFunction. You need stdarg(3) facilities. It would include code like
va_args arglist;
va_start (arglist, fun);
switch(sigkind) {
case funsig_int_to_void: {
int a = va_arg(arglis, int);
fun_int_to_void* fptr = (fun_int_to_void*)fun;
(*fptr)(a);
return;
} // end case funsig_int_to_void
much later you'll need some va_end(arglis); near the end of your functionWhichRecieveFunction body.
Another possibility is using varargs. In the following example every function being called does its own interpretation of parameters.
#include <stdio.h>
#include <stdarg.h>
// expects 4 arguments (int, int, int, char*)
void f1(va_list args) {
int a, b, c;
char *d;
a = va_arg(args, int);
b = va_arg(args, int);
c = va_arg(args, int);
d = va_arg(args, char *);
printf("%d, %d, %d: %s\n", a, b, c, d);
}
// expects 3 ars (int, int, char*);
void f2(va_list args) {
int a, b;
char *c;
a = va_arg(args, int);
b = va_arg(args, int);
c = va_arg(args, char *);
printf("%d, %d: %s\n", a, b, c);
}
void caller(void (*f)(va_list), ...) {
va_list args;
va_start(args, f);
f(args);
va_end(args);
}
int main() {
caller(&f1, 0, 1, 3, "hello");
caller(&f2, 1, 2, "bye");
return 0;
}
Another possibility is to have caller to interpret parameters based on some type info and call a correct function call. This might be useful if you have a limited number of argument patterns and just regular functions to call:
void f3(int a, int b, int c, char *d) {
printf("%d, %d, %d: %s\n", a, b, c, d);
}
void f4(int a, int b, char *c) {
printf("%d, %d: %s\n", a, b, c);
}
typedef enum {
type1, type2
} Types;
void caller1(Types t, void (*f)(), ...) {
va_list args;
va_start(args, f);
switch (t) {
case type1: {
int a, b, c;
char *d;
a = va_arg(args, int);
b = va_arg(args, int);
c = va_arg(args, int);
d = va_arg(args, char *);
f(a,b,c,d);
break;
}
case type2: {
int a, b;
char *c;
a = va_arg(args, int);
b = va_arg(args, int);
c = va_arg(args, char *);
f(a,b,c);
}
}
va_end(args);
}
int main() {
caller1(type1, &f3, 3,2,1, "hi");
caller1(type2, &f4, 3,2,"take care");
return 0;
#Paul Ogilvie, this is the code:
int f(int x, void *y) {
return x;
};
int g(int (*f)()) {
int x = f(1, NULL); // call f with parameters
printf("X is: %d", x);
return(x); // return result
};
int main()
{
//g( f(1, 2) ); // this passes the result of a call to f, not f
g( f ); // this passes f
return 0;
}
I want to pass multiple arguments to a function using a void pointer.
void* function(void *params)
{
//casting pointers
//doing something
}
int main()
{
int a = 0
int b = 10;
char x = 'S';
void function(???);
return 0;
}
I know that I have to cast them to a certain variable in my function but I do not know how I can pass my 3 arguments as one void pointer to my function.
I have searched for this problem know quite some time but I could not find anything that would help me.
You could do it like this:
struct my_struct
{
int a;
int b;
char x;
}
void * function(void * pv)
{
struct my_strcut * ps = pv; /* Implicitly converting the void-pointer
/* passed in to a pointer to a struct. */
/* Use ps->a, ps->b and ps->x here. */
return ...; /* NULL or any pointer value valid outside this function */
}
Use it like this
int main(void)
{
struct my_struct s = {42, -1, 'A'};
void * pv = function(&s);
}
Following up on the OP's update:
struct my_struct_foo
{
void * pv1;
void * pv2;
}
struct my_struct_bar
{
int a;
int b;
}
void * function(void * pv)
{
struct my_strcut_foo * ps_foo = pv;
struct my_struct_bar * ps_bar = ps_foo->pv1;
/* Use ps_foo->..., ps_bar->... here. */
return ...; /* NULL or any pointer value valid outside this function */
}
Use it like this
int main(void)
{
struct my_struct_bar s_bar = {42, -1};
struct my_struct_foo s_foo = {&s_bar, NULL};
void * pv = function(&s_foo);
}
The void* is used as a pointer to a "generic" type. Hence, you need to create a wrapping type, cast convert to void* to invoke the function, and cast convert back to your type in the function's body.
#include <stdio.h>
struct args { int a, b; char X; };
void function(void *params)
{
struct args *arg = params;
printf("%d\n", arg->b);
}
int main()
{
struct args prm;
prm.a = 0;
prm.b = 10;
prm.X = 'S';
function(&prm);
return 0;
}
After some research I didn't find a good way to implement the std::bind in C.
I build a small program that implements an equivalent of std::bind in C by hacking the stack.
There's two functions I will try to bind to function with pre-defined arguments.
My problem is this code is only working under Windows. Under Linux, this is a mess. I this the problem is my knowledge of the stack and the way that arguments are store in memory.
Thanks,
Please, find below the code I made:
#include <stdio.h>
#include <stdlib.h>
#include <string.h>
The two functions I want to bind :
void test1 (int nombre, char t, int nombre2)
{
printf ("test 1 : %d%c%d\n", nombre, t, nombre2);
}
void test2 (char t, int nombre, int nombre2)
{
printf ("test 2 : %c%d%d\n", t, nombre, nombre2);
}
Two struct that will store the argument of each function (order of fields is important).
typedef struct {
int nombre;
char t;
int nombre2;
} struct1;
typedef struct {
char t;
int nombre;
int nombre2;
} struct2;
This "fake" struct will be use to write on the stack by dereferencing a structvoid* variable.
// Size must be bigger than every struct*
typedef struct {
int i[10];
} structvoid;
The main function.
int main(int argc, char** argv) {
// Variables to store the two functions and their arguments.
void * functions[2];
structvoid * data[2];
void *func1 = (void *)&test1;
void *func2 = (void *)&test2;
void (*functionPtrc)(structurevoid);
// Definition of the argument of the first function test1
struct1 data1;
data1.nombre = 15;
data1.t = 'c';
data1.nombre2 = 30;
// and storing data.
void *datac = malloc (sizeof (structvoid));
memcpy(datac, &data1, sizeof (struct1));
data[0] = (structvoid*)datac;
functions[0] = func1;
// Same thing with function 2.
struct2 data2;
data2.t = 'a';
data2.nombre = 5;
data2.nombre2 = 10;
datac = malloc (sizeof (structvoid));
memcpy(datac, &data2, sizeof (struct2));
data[1] = (structvoid*)datac;
functions[1] = func2;
// Get the pointer to the first function (test1);
functionPtrc = functions[0];
// All the hack is here. By dereferencing the data, this will write on the stack all arguments need by the test1 function.
functionPtrc(*data[0]);
functionPtrc = functions[1];
functionPtrc(*data[1]);
// To check the result.
test1 (data1.nombre, data1.t, data1.nombre2);
test2 (data2.t, data2.nombre, data2.nombre2);
return 0;
}
EDIT
Here a new version of the program by calling function via the calling convention. I only wrote the new lines. The problem of this method is I can only store data inside a "void *" field. If I increase the size of structvoid, I got garbage behaviors.
// Structure that memories each argument
typedef struct {
void *i[1];
} structvoid;
int main(int argc, char** argv) {
// Variables to store the two functions and their arguments.
void * functions[2];
structvoid * data[2];
void *func1 = (void *)&test1;
// Let's start with a maximum of 5 arguments
void (*functionPtrc)(structurevoid, structurevoid, structurevoid, structurevoid, structurevoid);
// Definition of the argument of the first function test1
struct1 data1;
data1.nombre = 15;
data1.t = 'c';
data1.nombre2 = 30;
// and storing data.
structvoid *datac = malloc (sizeof (structvoid)*5);
memcpy(&datac[0], &data1.nombre, sizeof (data1.nombre));
memcpy(&datac[1], &data1.t, sizeof (data1.t));
memcpy(&datac[2], &data1.nombre2, sizeof (data1.nombre2));
data[0] = datac;
functions[0] = func1;
// Get the pointer to the first function (test1);
functionPtrc = functions[0];
// Call the function with the arguments. The unused argument will be ignored.
functionPtrc(data[0][0], data[0][1], data[0][2], data[0][3], data[0][4]);
}
Looking to see if anyone knows if its possible to swap C functions...?
void swap2(int(*a)(int), int(*b)(int)) {
int(*temp)(int) = a;
*a = *b;
*b = temp;
// Gives 'Non-object type 'int (int)' is not assignable
}
swap2(&funcA, &funcB);
EDIT
More data here as to intention -- Some answers have been provided below which do work such as creating the function ptr using typedef, pointing them to the functions and switching those, which lets you invoke the new swapped ptrs successfully.
BUT calling the functions by their original names after swapping shows no change. Essentially I'm looking for a c equivalent of the objc "swizzle".
I'm beginning to think this isn't possible, due to c's complete lack of reflection, and would require actually modifying the binary itself (obviously not feasible). D:
Comments welcome.
If you use the function pointers like below, it is yes
typedef int (*func_pt)(int);
func_pt a, b;
void swap(func_pt * a, func_pt * b)
{
func_pt tmp = *b;
*b = *a;
*a = tmp;
}
swap(&a, &b);
Or you use it as this, I think it is no:
int test1(int a)
{
return a;
}
int test2(int b)
{
return b;
}
swap(&test1, &test2);
Complete compiling working program
#include <stdio.h>
#include <stdlib.h>
typedef int (* func_pt)(int);
func_pt a, b;
int test1(int a)
{
printf("test1\n");
return 1;
}
int test2(int a)
{
printf("test2\n");
return 2;
}
void swap(func_pt * a, func_pt * b)
{
func_pt tmp = *b;
*b = *a;
*a = tmp;
}
int main(void)
{
a = &test1;
b = &test2;
printf("before\n");
a(1);
b(1);
swap(&a, &b);
printf("after\n");
a(1);
b(2);
return 0;
}
Output:
before
test1
test2
after
test2
test1
Some people do not try it by themselves, just say it absurd.So I give you a example.
I'm pretty sure you need pointers to function pointers to swap pointers, no? This type of swapping function swaps values; you really want to deal in addresses. The example function call wouldn't really work because C doesn't treat functions as first-class variables so you can't actually swap functions directly; you need to use pointers to function addresses, since addresses CAN be swapped:
void swap2(int(**a)(int), int(**b)(int)) {
int(*temp)(int) = *a;
*a = *b;
*b = *temp;
}
int(*func1)(int) = &foo;
int(*func2)(int) = &bar;
swap2(&func1, &func2);
Your code will give error like "invalid lvalue" at the time of assignment. As I can see in your code you are trying to swap pointers without changing its values so have a look on below solution.
void swap2(int(**a)(int), int(**b)(int)) {
int(*temp)(int) = *a;
*a = *b;
*b = temp;
}
int main(){
int(*temp1)(int) = &funcA;
int(*temp2)(int) = &funcB;
swap2(&temp1,&temp2);
}
Yes,you can. Think that a function-pointer is just a memory-address,the single requeriment is: where you will keep such address needs to be mutable. Say,int (*foo)() not really to where foo points to. May be to printf() or fopen().
Although the subject asks about swapping functions, you actually want to emulate what swizzle does. This just means you want to be able to call the same function name but have it do something different.
A pointer only solution will not give you that behavior. If that is not important to you, then you should adopt one of the function pointer only solutions provided. If it is important to you, then, you will need to introduce a layer of abstraction. The abstraction could use function pointers under the hood (although there are other solutions).
The API to users of this interface would be:
/* API to initialize */
void abstract_func_init ();
/* API to manipulate abstract functions */
typedef int abstract_func_type ();
abstract_func_type * abstract_func_get (abstract_func_type *key);
int abstract_func_set (abstract_func_type *key, abstract_func_type *behavior);
/* the abstract functions */
extern int foo ();
extern int bar ();
The implementation of such an interface could look like:
static void insert (abstract_func_type *key, abstract_func_type **behavior)
{ /* associate key to behavior */ }
static abstract_func_type ** lookup (abstract_func_type *key)
{ /* return behavior from key */ }
abstract_func_type * abstract_func_get (abstract_func_type *k) {
abstract_func_type **f = lookup(k);
if (f) return *f;
return 0;
}
int abstract_func_set (abstract_func_type *k, abstract_func_type *p) {
abstract_func_type **f = lookup(k);
if (f) {
*f = p;
return 0;
}
return -ENOENT;
}
#define DEFINE_ABSTRACT_FUNC(func) \
static int static_##func (); \
static abstract_func_type *func##_ptr = static_##func; \
int func () { return func##_ptr(); } \
static int static_##func ()
DEFINE_ABSTRACT_FUNC(foo) { return puts("foo"); }
DEFINE_ABSTRACT_FUNC(bar) { return puts("bar"); }
void abstract_func_init () {
insert(foo, &foo_ptr);
insert(bar, &bar_ptr);
}
Then, the swap() you initially presented in your post could be implemented like this:
void swap (abstract_func_type *a, abstract_func_type *b) {
abstract_func_type *ap = abstract_func_get(a);
abstract_func_type *bp = abstract_func_get(b);
abstract_func_set(a, bp);
abstract_func_set(b, ap);
}
Here is a program that calls swap():
puts("before swap");
foo();
bar();
swap(foo, bar);
puts("after swap");
foo();
bar();
And its output would be:
before swap
foo
bar
after swap
bar
foo
To automate the adding of abstract functions into the lookup table, you could introduce into the build system an extra step that called a script that would grep out the DEFINE_ABSTRACT_FUNC lines, and generate a new source file that had a function with the calls to insert() for each such line.
A complete version of the mock-up can be found here.