I am trying to read and write Birthday and Hiredate user properties using Microsoft graph API. I configured below app and delegated permissions.
I am getting access denied error as a normal user but working for azure admin.
Delegate
User.Read, User.ReadBasic.All, User.ReadWrite, Directory.AccessAsUser.All (admin only), Directory.Read.All (admin only), Directory.ReadWrite.All (admin only),User.Read.All (admin only),User.ReadWrite.All (admin only),
App
Directory.Read.All,Directory.ReadWriteAll (admin only),User.Read.All (admin only),User.ReadWrite.All (admin only)
Please help me which permissions needed for the app to read and write birthday and hire day properties for normal users.
You cannot have both Application and Delegated scopes active within the same token. Which are used are entirely based on the OAuth Grant you've used to obtain the token. You might find this article helpful: Application vs Delegated Scopes.
You've also chosen several scopes that require Admin Consent before they can be used within a tenant. Until you've obtained this consent, normal user's will not be able to authenticate. You might find this article helpful: v2 Endpoint & Admin Consent.
In terms of scopes, in order to read a user's profile (which holds those properties), you should only need User.Read. You can, and should, remove all of the other scopes you're requesting. When it comes to permission scopes, more is never better.
Note: both of the articles I mentioned above were written by me. Also, while they deal with the v2 Endpoint, the concepts in them apply to both AAD v1 and v2 OAuth endpoints
Related
My AD tenant has user consent disabled, i.e., all permissions added to AD app registration need an admin consent.
For an application using static permissions/scopes (v1.0 OAuth/OpenId endpoint), is it possible to add new permissions such that until the admin consent is granted, users can continue using features which require only the existing consented scopes?
Microsoft docs say: "The app needs to know all of the resources it would ever access ahead of time. It was difficult to create apps that could access an arbitrary number of resources." Does it mean that for my scenario, all users need to wait for admin consent before they can access the app?
I receive the below error when a user tries logging in to the app using the Open ID Connect flow. For reference, my login URL is similar to https://login.microsoftonline.com/{tenant}/oauth2/authorize?response_type=id_token&client_id=b8ad6a99-cd23-40a6-a1b4-1184af990aa2&redirect_uri=https%3A%2F%2Flocalhost%2F&state=13ccfb84-cfd1-4cb0-bfe3-bb2c227e19f7&client-request-id=4d76947a-0000-48af-aeff-7bc2d5e40000&x-client-SKU=Js&x-client-Ver=1.0.17&nonce=ef1caa16-d3fe-4523-a9c9-000000000000
is it possible to add new permissions such that until the admin consent is granted, users can continue using features which require only the existing consented scopes?
Yes, you can.
When the admin consent the API permission of an AD App(App registration), the permissions essentially will be given to the service principal(Enterprise application) in your AAD tenant. Actually if you use the AD App in your tenant, the permissions are essentially from the service principal.
You could refer to the screenshot below, there are four permissions, the two permission has been granted.
Navigate to the Overview, click the option Manage application in local directory.
Then in the Permissions, you will find the two permissions which have been consent.
When you add the new scopes, the app will keep working, but it will only be able to access the old scopes until the admin consents to the new scopes.
Thanks!
Alex Simons
I have been doing some R&D on using the MicrosoftGraphAPI to fetch the skus subscribed by my organization.
I have created an app as described in the documentation. I did all the steps in the above link except 'Assign application to role'.
Using postman am able to get the oauth2 token by sending a post request using the link
https://login.microsoftonline.com/<mytenantid>/oauth2/token
with the client_id, client_secret, resource(https://graph.microsoft.com) and grant_type(client_credentials) parameters.
After this token is obtained I can fire a get request https://graph.microsoft.com/v1.0/subscribedSkus with the Authorization header set as Bearer {token} which will return the SKUs subscribed by my organization.
So far so good. :-)
Now the requirement is I need to fetch the subscribed SKUs by one of the client (let's say having the azure ad tenant id 'ABCDEFG') of my organization.
I can successfully do that by registering an app in the client's tenant 'ABCDEFG' with the same steps as above.
This approach is fine if my organization has say 1 or 2 clients.
However, if the client numbers are more than say 30 this approach of registering an application in each Azure AD instance is not feasible.
If the application that I registered in my organizations AAD was multi-tenant then how should it help me?
What will be the steps needed to obtain the access token for each tenant?
Can somebody assist with some detailed explanation?
Since you need application-level access, you would assign one of the Application permissions listed in the documentation for getting SKUs: https://developer.microsoft.com/en-us/graph/docs/api-reference/v1.0/api/subscribedsku_list.
Directory.Read.All, Directory.ReadWrite.All
In this case you should require the Read Directory Data (Directory.Read.All) application permission.
Then you mark your app as multi-tenanted.
Now then in order for another org to use your app, they will have to be on-boarded.
You will need some kind of page where their administrator can click a button/link to start using your app.
This should redirect the admin to:
https://login.microsoftonline.com/common/oauth2/authorize?client_id=your-client-id&prompt=admin_consent&response_type=code+id_token&redirect_uri=url-where-to-send-user-back
Once they sign in, they will be presented with a consent screen, where they can approve the permissions that your app requires.
If and when they do that, they will be redirected back to your app (to the URL you specified) and you can use the Id token to know which Azure AD tenant registered.
During this process a service principal for your app is created in their tenant, and the required permission is granted to it.
This means you can then get an access token for their tenant from: (using the same credentials)
https://login.microsoftonline.com/their-tenant-id/oauth2/token
Remember that access tokens are specific to an Azure AD tenant, so you will have to get an access token for each tenant.
One thing I would like to point out is that you should instead try to use delegated permissions if possible.
The application permission given here gives quite large access to your app, and some admins might not use your service for that reason alone.
Delegated permissions are more complex to handle, but allow your app to act on behalf of a user instead of purely as itself.
When registering a native application on the Azure AD 1.0 endpoint, and assigning Graph API permissions, it seems like consented permissions are 'cached' somewhere and can't be managed properly.
Example scenario:
Application registered and permission scopes (incl. ones requiring admin consent) assigned.
Administrator consents to the permission scopes
Simple user can use the app with consented permissions.
Permission scopes change (adding a new one for example)
Same admin doesn't get the consent form anymore
Simple user is stuck with "consent required, have an admin account?"
Another global admin must use the app for the first time to trigger the consent page.
Note that #7 doesn't always work; even if the other admin provides consent, simple users can't get through sometimes.
This is a multi-tenant application, yet when start using it in another tenant, I can not see its consented permissions in the AAD portal under enterprise applications.
Shouldn't permissions that have been consented to be listed in other tenants so that the admin can at least see what has been consented to?
Also, when I register an app on the V1.0 endpoint in my own tenant, I have an option to 'grant permissions' centrally, from the Azure AD portal for my tenant.
This option isn't available if I'm looking at an application that was registered in another tenant.
Am I overlooking something? Any help much appreciated.
When you change permissions, it does not automatically re-consent (for user or admin). You can find a detailed overview of this at Understanding user and admin consent.
You'll first need kick off the Admin Consent workflow. For a multi-tenant app this is done by adding prompt=admin_consent to your OAUTH URL and having an Admin authenticate.
Once that is done you can also force existing users to re-consent as well by adding prompt=consent to your Auth URL.
We have created a converged application for a public community(AD & live users can login) using Microsoft Graph and the scopes openid, email, profile and user.readBasic.all.
Every thing works fine for live users but some of AD users are not able to login. When they try to login they get the message as
"App needs permission to access resources in your organization that
only an admin can grant. Please ask an admin to grant permission to
this app before you can use it."
as per Microsoft document we have prepared admin consent url as
https://login.microsoftonline.com/<TenantID>/oauth2/authorize?client_id=<AppID>&response_type=code&redirect_uri=<RedirectURI>&prompt=admin_consent
After admin consent also users are not able to login to the app. Please help us what we are missing here.
Your URL is for the v1 Endpoint, not the v2 Endpoint (aka converged endpoint).
It should look like this (line break for readability):
https://login.microsoftonline.com/common/adminconsent?
client_id=[APPLICATION ID]&redirect_uri=[REDIRECT URI]
Note that is it /adminconsent rather than /authorize and there isn't a prompt query parameter. Also keep in mind that you'll need to ensure your registration includes the scopes you want the consent for.
I've written an article that walks you through the entire process that should prove helpful here: v2 Endpoint and Admin Consent
We have a multi-tenant Saas application providing sign in using our username/pwd authentication system and using Azure AD (OAuth 2.0 flows). When a user signs in using Azure AD, we can get the user's profile using https://graph.windows.net/{tenantid}/me. We want however to get more information using the memberOf or getMemberGroups operations to retrieve the user's groups in the tenants directory, to map specific groups from the tenant to an organizational structure in our application. However these operations always fail with a Forbidden statuscode. Are we missing required permissions or is it just not possible to query for the groups and roles of another tenant.
Thanks in advance
This is totally possible, but today requires that you request the "Read Directory" permission. This permission does require and admin of the tenant to consent. We are looking at adding some additional fine grained permissions for Graph API that will allow users to consent (to get group membership information).
Another option for you is to configure your application to request group membership claims (which should appear in any user or JWT token). You can do this by going to the azure management portal and getting to your app's config page. From there download the application manifest file and update the groupMembershipClaims property. You can see most of the properties in the application manifest described here: https://msdn.microsoft.com/en-us/library/azure/dn151677.aspx. Once updated, you can upload this app manifest file, and this will configure your application accordingly. Once done, AAD will issue group membership claims in the token. Dushyant has written a nice blog about authorizing access to a web app, using group membership claims or app roles. You can find it via Alex Simons blog post here: http://blogs.technet.com/b/ad/archive/2014/12/18/azure-active-directory-now-with-group-claims-and-application-roles.aspx
HTHs