Dynamic SQL to execute large number of rows from a table - sql-server

Question

I have a table with a very large number of rows which I wish to execute via dynamic SQL. They are basically existence checks and insert statements and I want to migrate data from one production database to another - we are merging transactional data. I am trying to find the optimal way to execute the rows.
I've been finding the coalesce method for appending all the rows to one another to not be efficient for this particularly when the number of rows executed at a time is greater than ~100.
Assume the structure of the source table is something arbitrary like this:
CREATE TABLE [dbo].[MyTable]
(
[ID] [int] IDENTITY(1,1) NOT NULL,
[DataField1] [int] NOT NULL,
[FK_ID1] [int] NOT NULL,
[LotsMoreFields] [NVARCHAR] (MAX),
CONSTRAINT [PK_MyTable] PRIMARY KEY CLUSTERED ([ID] ASC)
)
CREATE TABLE [dbo].[FK1]
(
[ID] [int] IDENTITY(1,1) NOT NULL,
[Name] [int] NOT NULL, -- Unique constrained value
CONSTRAINT [PK_FK1] PRIMARY KEY CLUSTERED ([ID] ASC)
)
The other requirement is I am tracking the source table PK vs the target PK and whether an insert occurred or whether I have already migrated that row to the target. To do this, I'm tracking migrated rows in another table like so:
CREATE TABLE [dbo].[ChangeTracking]
(
[ReferenceID] BIGINT IDENTITY(1,1),
[Src_ID] BIGINT,
[Dest_ID] BIGINT,
[TableName] NVARCHAR(255),
CONSTRAINT [PK_ChangeTracking] PRIMARY KEY CLUSTERED ([ReferenceID] ASC)
)
My existing method is executing some dynamic sql generated by a stored procedure. The stored proc does PK lookups as the source system has different PK values for table [dbo].[FK1].
E.g.
IF NOT EXISTS (<ignore this existence check for now>)
BEGIN
INSERT INTO [Dest].[dbo].[MyTable] ([DataField1],[FK_ID1],[LotsMoreFields]) VALUES (333,(SELECT [ID] FROM [Dest].[dbo].[FK1] WHERE [Name]=N'ValueFoundInSource'),N'LotsMoreValues');
INSERT INTO [Dest].[dbo].[ChangeTracking] ([Src_ID],[Dest_ID],[TableName]) VALUES (666,SCOPE_IDENTITY(),N'MyTable'); --666 is the PK in [Src].[dbo].[MyTable] for this inserted row
END
So when you have a million of these, it isn't quick.
Is there a recommended performant way of doing this?

Answer 1

As mentioned, the MERGE statement works well when you're looking at a complex JOIN condition (if any of these fields are different, update the record to match). You can also look into creating a HASHBYTES hash of the entire record to quickly find differences between source and target tables, though that can also be time-consuming on very large data sets.

Answer 2

It sounds like you're making these updates like a front-end developer, by checking each row for a match and then doing the insert. It will be far more efficient to do the inserts with a single query. Below is an example that looks for names that are in the tblNewClient table, but not in the tblClient table:
INSERT INTO tblClient
( [Name] ,
TypeID ,
ParentID
)
SELECT nc.[Name] ,
nc.TypeID ,
nc.ParentID
FROM tblNewClient nc
LEFT JOIN tblClient cl
ON nc.[Name] = cl.[Name]
WHERE cl.ID IS NULL;
This is will way more efficient than doing it RBAR (row by agonizing row).

Answer 3

Taking the two answers from #RusselFox and putting them together, I reached this tentative solution (but looking a LOT more efficient):
MERGE INTO [Dest].[dbo].[MyTable] [MT_D]
USING (SELECT [MT_S].[ID] as [SrcID],[MT_S].[DataField1],[FK_1_D].[ID] as [FK_ID1],[MT_S].[LotsMoreFields]
FROM [Src].[dbo].[MyTable] [MT_S]
JOIN [Src].[dbo].[FK_1] ON [MT_S].[FK_ID1] = [FK_1].[ID]
JOIN [Dest].[dbo].[FK_1] [FK_1_D] ON [FK_1].[Name] = [FK_1_D].[Name]
) [SRC] ON 1 = 0
WHEN NOT MATCHED THEN
INSERT([DataField1],[FL_ID1],[LotsMoreFields])
VALUES ([DataField1],[FL_ID1],[LotsMoreFields])
OUTPUT [SRC].[SrcID],INSERTED.[ID],0,N'MyTable' INTO [Dest].[dbo].[ChangeTracking]([Src_ID],[Dest_ID],[AlreadyExists],[TableName]);