Attempting to split and store arrays similar to strtok - c

Question

For an assignment in class, we have been instructed to write a program which takes a string and a delimiter and then takes "words" and stores them in a new array of strings. i.e., the input ("my name is", " ") would return an array with elements "my" "name" "is".
Roughly, what I've attempted is to:
Use a separate helper called number_of_delimeters() to determine the size of the array of strings
Iterate through the initial array to find the number of elements in a given string which would be placed in the array
Allocate storage within my array for each string
Store the elements within the allocated memory
Include directives:
#include <stdlib.h>
#include <stdio.h>
This is the separate helper:
int number_of_delimiters (char* s, int d)
{
int numdelim = 0;
for (int i = 0; s[i] != '\0'; i++)
{
if (s[i] == d)
{
numdelim++;
}
}
return numdelim;
}
`This is the function itself:
char** split_at (char* s, char d)
{
int numdelim = number_of_delimiters(s, d);
int a = 0;
int b = 0;
char** final = (char**)malloc((numdelim+1) * sizeof(char*));
for (int i = 0; i <= numdelim; i++)
{
int sizeofj = 0;
while (s[a] != d)
{
sizeofj++;
a++;
}
final[i] = (char*)malloc(sizeofj);
a++;
int j = 0;
while (j < sizeofj)
{
final[i][j] = s[b];
j++;
b++;
}
b++;
final[i][j+1] = '\0';
}
return final;
}
To print:
void print_string_array(char* a[], unsigned int alen)
{
printf("{");
for (int i = 0; i < alen; i++)
{
if (i == alen - 1)
{
printf("%s", a[i]);
}
else
{
printf("%s ", a[i]);
}
}
printf("}");
}
int main(int argc, char *argv[])
{
print_string_array(split_at("Hi, my name is none.", ' '), 5);
return 0;
}
This currently returns {Hi, my name is none.}
After doing some research, I realized that the purpose of this function is either similar or identical to strtok. However, looking at the source code for this proved to be little help because it included concepts we have not yet used in class.
I know the question is vague, and the code rough to read, but what can you point to as immediately problematic with this approach to the problem?

Answer 1

The program has several problems.
while (s[a] != d) is wrong, there is no delimiter after the last word in the string.
final[i][j+1] = '\0'; is wrong, j+1 is one position too much.
The returned array is unusable, unless you know beforehand how many elements are there.

Answer 2

Just for explanation:
strtok will modify the array you pass in! After
char test[] = "a b c ";
for(char* t = test; strtok(t, " "); t = NULL);
test content will be:
{ 'a', 0, 'b', 0, 'c', 0, 0 }
You get subsequently these pointers to your test array: test + 0, test + 2, test + 4, NULL.
strtok remembers the pointer you pass to it internally (most likely, you saw a static variable in your source code...) so you can (and must) pass NULL the next time you call it (as long as you want to operate on the same source string).
You, in contrast, apparently want to copy the data. Fine, one can do so. But here we get a problem:
char** final = //...
return final;
void print_string_array(char* a[], unsigned int alen)
You just return the array, but you are losing length information!
How do you want to pass the length to your print function then?
char** tokens = split_at(...);
print_string_array(tokens, sizeof(tokens));
will fail, because sizeof(tokens) will always return the size of a pointer on your local system (most likely 8, possibly 4 on older hardware)!
My personal recommendation: create a null terminated array of c strings:
char** final = (char**)malloc((numdelim + 2) * sizeof(char*));
// ^ (!)
// ...
final[numdelim + 1] = NULL;
Then your print function could look like this:
void print_string_array(char* a[]) // no len parameter any more!
{
printf("{");
if(*a)
{
printf("%s", *a); // printing first element without space
for (++a; *a; ++a) // *a: checking, if current pointer is not NULL
{
printf(" %s", *a); // next elements with spaces
}
}
printf("}");
}
No problems with length any more. Actually, this is exactly the same principle C strings use themselves (the terminating null character, remember?).
Additionally, here is a problem in your own code:
while (j < sizeofj)
{
final[i][j] = s[b];
j++; // j will always point behind your string!
b++;
}
b++;
// thus, you need:
final[i][j] = '\0'; // no +1 !
For completeness (this was discovered by n.m. already, see the other answer): If there is no trailing delimiter in your source string,
while (s[a] != d)
will read beyond your input string (which is undefined behaviour and could result in your program crashing). You need to check for the terminating null character, too:
while(s[a] && s[a] != d)
Finally: how do you want to handle subsequent delimiters? Currently, you will insert empty strings into your array? Print out your strings as follows (with two delimiting symbols - I used * and + like birth and death...):
printf("*%s+", *a);
and you will see. Is this intended?
Edit 2: The variant with pointer arithmetic (only):
char** split_at (char* s, char d)
{
int numdelim = 0;
char* t = s; // need a copy
while(*t)
{
numdelim += *t == d;
++t;
}
char** final = (char**)malloc((numdelim + 2) * sizeof(char*));
char** f = final; // pointer to current position within final
t = s; // re-assign t, using s as start pointer for new strings
while(*t) // see above
{
if(*t == d) // delimiter found!
{
// can subtract pointers --
// as long as they point to the same array!!!
char* n = (char*)malloc(t - s + 1); // +1: terminating null
*f++ = n; // store in position pointer and increment it
while(s != t) // copy the string from start to current t
*n++ = *s++;
*n = 0; // terminate the new string
}
++t; // next character...
}
*f = NULL; // and finally terminate the string array
return final;
}

Answer 3

While I've now been shown a more elegant solution, I've found and rectified the issues in my code:
char** split_at (char* s, char d)
{
int numdelim = 0;
int x;
for (x = 0; s[x] != '\0'; x++)
{
if (s[x] == d)
{
numdelim++;
}
}
int a = 0;
int b = 0;
char** final = (char**)malloc((numdelim+1) * sizeof(char*));
for (int i = 0; i <= numdelim; i++)
{
int sizeofj = 0;
while ((s[a] != d) && (a < x))
{
sizeofj++;
a++;
}
final[i] = (char*)malloc(sizeofj);
a++;
int j = 0;
while (j < sizeofj)
{
final[i][j] = s[b];
j++;
b++;
}
final[i][j] = '\0';
b++;
}
return final;
}
I consolidated what I previously had as a helper function, and modified some points where I incorrectly incremented .