I was confused about my assumption as to how the while loop might work ..
I've tried it on my computer, and seen that all cases have been as expected,
am i right, or am i missing out on something ?
while(scanf("%d%d%d",&a,&b,&c) ,a||b||c ) { /* some code */ }
This means that even if one value (either a,b or c ) is non zero , it will loop on
while(scanf("%d%d%d",&a,&b,&c) ,a&&b&&c ) { /* some code */ }
This means whenever any of a, b or c becomes zero, the loop terminates
This is correct, the first loop will go on until all three values turn zero, while the second loop will stop as soon as one of three items becomes zero.
This is because comma operator discards the result of the first expression - essentially, the expression a || b || c or a && b && c become your loop condition.
Note that your loops may not terminated when the input ends prior to reading a stopping combination (all zeros / one zero). When this happens, your loop becomes infinite. To prevent this from happening, change your loops to
while(scanf("%d%d%d",&a,&b,&c) == 3 && (a||b||c) ) { //some code }
or
while(scanf("%d%d%d",&a,&b,&c) == 3 && a && b && c) ) { //some code }
while(true) {//some code} // loop will run
while(false) {//some code} // loop will not run
since any value other than 0 is considered as true so your first while loop will execute until all of them become 0.
and in second while loop if any of them become 0 the loop will not execute.
just basic operators.
Related
I have a homework assignment in which I believe the professor has made a typo, typing if(!(a=10)) instead of if(!(a==10)). However, when asked if this was typo, she told me to "assume that the equations are correct and give your answer." Specifically, the assignment is to describe the behavior of the program:
#include <stdio.h>
int main() {
int a = 100;
while (1) {
if (!(a=10)) {
break;
}
}
return 0;
}
If the offensive code read (!(a==10)) then the program would enter the if loop, reach the break and exit both loops, which makes sense for a beginner-level course in C programming.
However, if, truly, the code is meant to read (!(a=10)) then I don't know what the compiler will interpret that to mean. I do know that the code compiles, and when you run it in UNIX, it just allows you to input whatever you want using the keyboard, like say the number "7", and then you press enter and it moves to a new line, and you can enter "dog", and move to a new line, and on and on and it never exits back to the command line. So (1) how would the compiler interpret (!(a=10))? And (2) why does the program allow you to just continue to input entries forever?
Thanks!
For the first question,
What's the meaning of if( !(a=10) ){break;},
It's equivalent to
a = 10; if(!a) {break;}
For a value of 10 !a will be 0 and it never breaks the while loop.
In this particular example, if you assign if(!(a=0)), then it will exit the loop;
For the second question, there is no code present in your example.
But first question's answer can be extended here as the loop never breaks it keeps on asking the input values.
From the C Standard (6.5.3.3 Unary arithmetic operators ¶5)
5 The result of the logical negation operator ! is 0 if the value of
its operand compares unequal to 0, 1 if the value of its operand
compares equal to 0. The result has type int. The expression !E is
equivalent to (0==E).
So according to the quote the if statement
if (!(a=10)) {
is equivalent to
if ( ( a = 10 ) == 0 ) {
As the value of the assignment sub-expression, a = 10 is equal to 10 that is it is not equal to 0 then the condition of the if statement evaluates to logical false and the sub-statement of the if statement will not get the control and you will have an infinite while loop.
In fact, you can rewrite this while loop
while (1) {
if (!(a=10)) {
break;
}
}
the following way with the same effect
while ( ( a = 10 ) ) {}
or just
while ( ( a = 10 ) );
or more simply:
while ( a != 0 );
because what is important is that within the while loop the variable a does become equal to 0.
while (1) {
if (!(a=10)) {
break;
}
}
as !(a = 10) is always zero (false) it is equivalent of:
while (1) {
}
for(i=1;i=-1;i++)
if(i<5) break;
printf("%d\n",i);
i was asked to write the output of the following code, i could not understand as the second argument should have been a condition, but here it was an assignment,
output: -1
i cant understand how it is possible, so i tried to experiment with the code
int i=1;
while(i=-1)
{
printf("condition is true\n");
if(i<5) break;
}
printf("%d\n",i);
the output of the following code is
output: condition is true
-1
can anyone explain how the above two codes work
and how is while(i=-1) evaluated to TRUE??
The condition is always true. Because the value of an assignment statement is the value assigned. So -1 is non-zero and non-zero value is considered as true in c so it is always true.
The correct usage would be == which compares the value and returns 1 or 0 based on the equality or non-equality.
So here when you did i = -1 and put in the while loop condition - it boils down to
while( -1 ){
...
/* break here */
}
And as -1 is considered as true in c because of it being nonzero - the loop condition evaluates to true.
The break statement here is given here so that this loop doesn't turn to be an infinite loop.
The syntax of a for loop in C is
for(expr1, expr2; expr3)
/* body of loop */
Now, conventionally, expr1 is the loop initialization, and expr2 is the condition under which to keep going, and expr3 is the increment between loops. But that's only a convention -- in actuality, the compiler just arranges to execute expr1 once, then expr2 to decide whether to take another trip through the loop or not, then expr3 at the bottom of the loop. So it's more or less equivalent to
expr1;
while(expr2) {
/* body of loop */
expr3;
}
Or, stated another way:
expr1;
while(1) {
if(!expr2) break;
/* body of loop */
expr3;
}
But then the other key point is that, yes, the expression
i = -1
doesn't look much like a condition; it looks like an assignment. But in C, when you use an expression as a condition (that is, in a context where what we care about is whether the expression is "false" or "true", all we really care about is whether the expression evaluates to zero or to non-zero. And the value of an assignment expression is simply the value that was assigned. So the value of
i = -1
is -1, and that's not zero, so it's interpreted as "true". So if you say
while(i = -1) {
/* body of loop */
}
the condition is always "true", so it will be an infinite loop, unless there's a break statement in the body somewhere (or a return, or a call to exit(), or something like that).
First for loop one does nothing and will be removed from the generated code if the optimisation is on
Second one enters the loop one time. The actual loop will be removed by the optimising compiler and replaced by the puts, initialisation and printf call.
https://godbolt.org/g/T5wgqt
printf with the format string only is replaced by the puts
How this for loop is working
int main(){
char i=0;
for(i<=5 && i>=-1; ++i ;i>0)
printf("%d \n",i);
printf("\n");
return 0;
}
Ahh thanks for the clarification.
Your asking why the for loop in your example is executing, even though the increment operand and loop condition have been swapped, and the fact that the variable is a char. Lets consider the proper structure of a for loop:
for (initialise variable; for condition; increment variable)
{
//Do stuff
}
The answer to your question is simple:
Your condition increases i by 1, but as you have pointed out, i is a char. Using operands on a char can convert it to another type, including int (refer C comparison char and int)
A loop will continue until its condition == false.
Your loop will continue running until i=0, which means it will continue to increase by 1 until it reaches 128, at which point it will overflow to -128 and continue to increase until it reaches 0 again.
Lets name parts of the for loop:
for( Expr1; Expr2; Expr3 )
DoStuff;
This is how a for loop works:
1. It executes Expr1 first. in your loop does nothing in fact, since it doesn't check the result of this execution.
Then it executes Expr2 and treat it's result as a condition if it's 0 terminates the loop, if it's "not 0" go to step 3. In your loop this means that i will be incremented, thus it's now 1, so result is true.
Then it runs the DoStuff part, in your case print out i value
Next it executes Expr3, no check, just run it, in your case does nothing again, since it's a condition and its result isn't used.
Next it goes back to Expr2 executes it and check it's result. now i is 2, still a true condition.
Again execute the DoStuff part and go to step 4
The loop will stop once i value changes back to 0.
When? since it's type is char, after reaching 127 it will overflow to -128 and then increment back to -1 and then 0. and stop.
Whenever you want to understand for loop in this kind of situation you can convert for loop into while to understand it.
The for syntax is:
for (initialization; condition; operation)
...
It can be converted into while as:
initialization;
while (condition) {
...
operation;
}
So in your case
i <= 5 && i >= -1; // Initialization
while(++i) { //condition
printf("%d \n", i);
i > 0; // operation
}
Initialization part will be execute once it will check for condition.Here in your case it is ++i so increment every time.Here i>0 means if i==0 then loop will stop it does not matter i is positive or negative Thumb rule to remember in this kind of situation is if (i == 0 ) then true else false. i>0 remains true)in every case after that so loop is infinite.
To understand for loop best answer I have seen in SO is this
There's not rule about the order of for loop condition and increment operation, the latter even don't need to be an increment operation. What it's expected to do is determined by you. The code is just same as the following semantically.
char i = 0;
i <= 5 && i >= -1; // Run before the loop and only once. No real effect here.
while (++i) { // Condition used to determine the loop should continue or break
printf("%d \n", i);
i > 0; // Run every time inside the loop. No real effect here.
}
BTW: It'll be an infinite loop (because ++i is a nonzero value until overflow).
First of all I'm not even sure whether you call it a member, couldn't think of a better term.
I'm trying to learn basics of debugging and arrays - so I wanted to create something resembling insert-sort from memory (so mistakes would be made) and then debug the program.
void findingsmaller (int *array, int num_inputs){
int a = 0;
int b = 1;
for ( b=1; b == num_inputs-1; b++ ) {
if ( array[a] > array[b] ) {
goleft(array, a, b);
a++;
}
}
}
Let's say we have this in array: 6 5 3 1 8 7 2 4. array[a] should be 6 and array[b] should be 5. 6 > 5 so we should enter the function that would find the first smaller number on the left of the array.
From my debugging session it seems like the condition is FALSE so I don't enter goleft at all. More specifically, Step into ignores it, the testing printf wasn't executed either. I'm assuming the array comparison is not written properly, what's the correction?
WHOLE CODE if somebody wants to see other possible mistakes.
Thank you in advance!
EDIT: <= num_inputs is correct, somehow I thought for has (range1, range2, change) instead of (start, condition, change). Anyway, now the problem seems that my goleft function does its do-while cycle one time too many although it shouldn't get past that condition.
EDIT2: A couple of other mistakes were fixed.
My printing in main is now for( ; i <= num_inputs-1; )
My goleft would do too many iterations due to the condition, fixed into ... while ( a >= 0 && array[a] > array[b] )
My findingsmaller would only operate if the number next is smaller but does nothing when the number is greater. For example for 6 8 the program wouldn't function properly. Added else {a++}
My fixed code for anyone interested in the comparison of the changes.
The for loop is executed as long as the condition is True.
for ( ;Condition; )
{
// body
}
In your for loop, the condition is always False if the input is greater than 1.
Instead of b == num_inputs - 1, you should put b < num_inputs in your for loop condition. Since the equality isn't true on the first iteration of the loop, it is immediately breaking.
I was looking a little bit at your code and i notice something that doesnt work.
while (scanf("%d", &array[i]) != EOF)
As the documentation of the function scanf say :
The return value is EOF for an error
your while condition was making you num_imputs reaching 200 even if there was only 3 inputs. I would replace EOF by '\n'.
while (scanf("%d", &array[i]) != '\n') /* stop when the user input '\n' you
can replace with any character you want to make it stop. */
I did not make a lot of test but this should make your program work fine.
can anyone explain the working of the for loop in the following code:
#include<stdio.h>
#include<conio.h>
int main()
{
char i=0;
for(i<=5&&i>=-1;++i;i>0)
printf("%d\n",i);
getch();
}
Let's break the for statement down, we have three phases, the initialiser, the test, and the modifier:
for(<Initialiser>; <Test>; <Modifier>)
<content>;
In your case:
for(i<=5&&i>=-1;++i;i>0)
// initialiser: i<=5&&i>=-1;
// test: ++i;
// modifier: i>0
The initialiser is done first. Here no assignment is done. Two boolean expressions (denoted by the >= and <= operators are compared in a logical &&. The whole initialiser returns a boolean value but it doesn't do anything. It could be left as a blank ; and there would be no change.
The test uses the pre-increment operator and so returns the result of i+1. If this result is ever 0 it evaluates as false and the loop will terminate. For any non-zero value it evaluates to true and continues. This is often used when i is initialised to a value less than zero and so the test will increment i until i+1 results in a zero, at which point the loop terminates.
Finally we have the modifier, which in this case simply uses the > operator to evaluate to a boolean value. No assignment is done here either.
The fact is that you've gotten the test and the modifier confused and put them in the wrong positions but before we sort that out let's see how it would work…
We begin with:
char i = 0;
…and for all intents and purposes this does the same thing as our for loops initialiser would do in normal circumstances. The next thing to be evaluated is the for loop's initialiser:
i<=5 && i>=-1;
Because i is 0 it is less-than-or-equal-to 5 and it is greater-than-or-equal-to -1. This expression evaluates to 1 but nothing is done with that value. All we've done is waste a bit of time with an evaluation.
Next up is the modifier to test whether or not the for loop's inner block should be executed:
++i;
This evaluates to 1 and also assigns that value to i. Now, as it's evaluated to a non-zero number, the loop executes:
printf("%d\n",i);
And the digit 1 is printed to the screen... Now it's the modifier that gets executed:
i>0
Well, i is 1 so that is greater-than 0. This evaluates to 1 (or true). Either way, this is ignored. The purpose of the modifier isn't to test or check anything. It's there so that you can change the state of the program each time the for loop iterates. Either way, the loop repeats and it will do this for a very long time. Why? Because ++i is going to evaluate to a non-zero number for a while. Whether or not it will ever terminate depends on how your system deals with integer overflows.
This is what you meant to do:
#include<stdio.h>
#include<conio.h>
int main()
{
for(char i=0; i<=5&&i>=-1; ++i)
printf("%d\n",i);
}
Do you see the difference? Our initialiser now starts the loop with the state of i as zero. We then test if it's within the bounds of -1 to 5 and each time we iterate we increment i by 1. This loop will output:
0
1
2
3
4
5
This snippet:
for(i<=5&&i>=-1;++i;i>0)
printf("%d\n",i);
Does the same as this:
i<=5 && i>=-1; //statement with no effect
while(++i)
{
printf("%d\n",i);
i>0; //statement with no effect
}
So, it's going to print i until ++i evaluates to 0. This will happen after i overflows and becomes negative, then incrementing towards 0. That will take 255 iterations to happen, since chars can store up to 256 different values.
for ( variable initialization; condition; variable update ) {
}
the variable initialization phase is done only once when the for loop starts.
the condition is checked everytime before running code inside the loop. if the condition is false then the loop is exited.
the variable update is done after the first iteration, from the second iteration it is done before the condition check.