C: Stack element overwritten by a function call - c

Question

I'm doing a school assignment, I've I've run into 2 problems. I have to simulate stacks, with arrays.
My current code is as follows:
#include <stdlib.h>
#include <stdio.h>
typedef struct {
int capacity;
int * array;
int size;
} stack_tt;
int pop(stack_tt * stack_p);
void push(stack_tt * stack_p, int value);
int top(stack_tt * stack_p);
stack_tt * newStack(void);
int empty(stack_tt * stack_p);
int main() {
stack_tt * myStack = newStack();
push(myStack, 123);
push(myStack, 99);
push(myStack, 4444);
while (!empty(myStack)) {
int value;
value = pop(myStack);
printf("popped: %d\n", value);
}
return 0; }
stack_tt * newStack(){
stack_tt * newS = malloc(sizeof(stack_tt) * 20);
(*newS).capacity = 1;
(*newS).size = 0;
return newS;
}
void push(stack_tt * stack_p, int value){
if ((*stack_p).size >= (*stack_p).capacity) {
(*stack_p).capacity*=2;
//realloc(stack_p, stack_p->capacity * sizeof(stack_tt));
}
(*stack_p).array = &value;
(*stack_p).size++;
}
int pop(stack_tt * stack_p){
(*stack_p).size--;
int fap = *(*stack_p).array;
return fap;
}
int empty(stack_tt * stack_p){
if ((*stack_p).size >= 1)
return 0;
return 1;
}
Fist of, when I call the line
while(!empty(myStack))
It changes the value in my array to 1.
secondly I'm not able to change individual values in my array, whenever I try things like:
(*stack_p).array[0] = value;
It doesn't know where in the memory to look.
I hope someone is able to help me out :)

Answer 1

There are a couple of problems with the code as I see it.
Lets take the push function where you do
(*stack_p).array = &value;
That will make the array structure member point to the local variable value, and once the function returns the variable cease to exist leaving you with a stray pointer and using that pointer will lead to undefined behavior.
The second problem with that code is that your stack will only be pointing (illegally) to the last element added.
You must allocate memory explicitly for array and use capacity to keep track of how much memory is allocated. The use size as an index into the allocated array for the pushing and popping. Something like
stack_tt * newStack(){
stack_tt * newS = malloc(sizeof(stack_tt)); // Only allocate *one* structure
newS->capacity = 0; // Start with zero capacity
newS->size = 0;
newS->array = NULL;
return newS;
}
void push(stack_tt * stack_p, int value){
if (stack_p->size + 1 > stack_p->capacity){
// Increase capacity by ten elements
int new_capacity = stack_p->capacity + 10;
int * temp_array = realloc(stack_p->array, new_capacity * sizeof(int));
if (temp_srray == NULL)
return;
stack_p->capacity = new_capacity;
stack_p->array = temp_array;
}
stack_p->array[stack_p->size++] = value;
}
int pop(stack_tt * stack_p){
if (stack_p->size > 0)
return stack_p->array[--stack_p->size];
return 0;
}
int empty(stack_tt * stack_p){
return stack_p->size == 0;
}

Answer 2

There is no need to allocate space for 20 structs of type stack_tt, you only need to allocate space for one:
stack_tt * newS = malloc(sizeof(stack_tt));
however you need to allocate space for elements of the struct member array:
newS->array = malloc( sizeof(int)*20);
newS->size = 0;
newS->capacity = 20;
now you can use the array member.
When you push a value to the 'stack', you shouldn't overwrite the array member with the address of the local variable, that doesn't make sense and will cause undefined behavior in addition of loosing the previously allocated memory. Instead simply assign the value to the member array, in the function push:
stack_p->array[stack_p->size] = value;
stack_p->size++;
Similarly when you pop an element, take the current element from the member array:
stack_p->size--;
int fap = stack_p->array[stack_p->size];
The rest of the functions and code should be fixed in the same manner.

Answer 3

You're code is good, but probably you didn't understand the usage of realloc:
//realloc(stack_p, stack_p->capacity * sizeof(stack_tt));
This function returns a pointer to the newly allocated memory, or NULL if the request fails.
The realloc (as the function suggests) takes the memory pointed by the pointer you pass, and copies that memory block in a new and resized block. So the right code should be.
stack_p->array = realloc(stack_p->array, stack_p->capacity * sizeof(stack_tt));
This other line is wrong:
(*stack_p).array = &value;
Change it with:
stack_p->array[stack_p->size] = value;
Another little suggestion, every (*stack_p). can be replaced by stack_p->, which is more elegant.
In the newStack() you're mallocing 20 structs which is kinda useless. You just need one.
Then you should malloc the array for the first time:
newS->array = malloc(sizeof(int));
newS->capacity = 1;