I've been struggling for 2 days now on how to secure a REST API without user authentification.
What does it mean ?
In my AngularJS application I identify an user by sending a GET request to an existing service (companydomain/userinfo) which I must use. I'm not sure how this work since I am not the author of this piece of code but the point is that I get the information about the user in the response as JSON (active directory name, phone in the company...).
This is all I have to identify an user.
What I did
Now, I found a lot of resources talking about OAuth, unique token, etc. but nothing seems to match with my issue. I implemented a token system but it's plain useless since I can't be sure of the authenticity of the requester.
User open the application. Application ask the service about the information related to the user. companydomain/userinfo
Application request a token to the server (nodejs & express), based on the information returned. /api/token/get/{user_info}
Server generates an unique token and store it in memory with expiration date and owner. The server also check in the table "authorized users" if the user exists (based on the active directory name), if not a new entry is added to it.
Application send the token along each request to the API. /api/entry/delete/{entry_id}
I think you see what is wrong here, an attacker could easily make a corrupted request to the API to get a legit token. So my question is :
How can I manage to secure my API since users don't use credentials to authentify ?
I hope my question is clear enough and at this point I am not even sure I can get around this issue without adding a credentials system.
You might want to look at Passport. It is a platform that allows you to easily add authentication to your application. There are many authentication strategies available. I am using Passport in a Node.js application implementing my own hmac strategy.
To authenticate, the client request includes an API ID to identify who the caller is and also includes an signature of a specified part of the message that includes things like the HTTP method, the API ID, a date value and some other header values, like maybe content-type. What data to include in the string to sign is up to you in your implementation, but the client and server must create and sign the same strings for the authentication to work. The signature is created by doing an hmac hash of the string using a shared secret.
On the server side, you use the API ID to retrieve the shared secret (possibly from a database or the filesystem) and perform the same hash on the request. If the hmac values match then you've authenticated the request. To prevent playback attacks, the date is included in the signed part of the request and must be within a certain window of the server's current time. For example, you might reject the request if the timestamp is more than 30 seconds old.
To enable a new user of your API, you generate a new API ID and shared secret. You give both of those to your API user and you store them for look up in your database or filesystem. The user must sign the requests with the shared secret and include the ID in the request.
The Hawk strategy provides much of this functionality, but we decided to roll our own hmac strategy.
Because you say that the user info endpoint returns active directory name, I assume you're on the Windows platform.
If so, why not use Windows integrated authentication (Kerberos) to authenticate your users without asking them for credentials? This will only work within your active directory domain, but is completely transparent to your service.
You can still call the user info endpoint and verify that the info it returns is for the same user that is calling your REST service.
If you need to call services that do not support Windows integrated auth, you could generate a security token (sign it to guarantee integrity) and make the other services trust this token.
Related
I'm developing the restful web app that using some popular web framework on the backend, say (rails, sinatra, flask, express.js). Ideally, I want to develop client side with Backbone.js. How do I let only my javascript client side interact with those API calls? I don't want those API calls to be public and be called by curl or simply by entering the link on browser.
As a first principle, if your API is consumed by your JS client, you have to assume, that it is public: A simple JS debugger puts an attacker into a position, where he can send a byte-for-byte identical request from a tool of his choice.
That said, if I read your question correctly, this is not, what you want to avoid: What you really don't want to happen is, that your API is consumed (on a regular basis) without your JS client being involved. Here are some ideas on how to if not enforce, then at least encourage using your client:
I am sure, your API has some sort of authentication field (e.g. Hash computed on the client). If not, take a look at This SO question. Make sure you use a salt (or even API key) that is given to your JS client on a session basis (a.o.t. hardcoded). This way, an unauthorized consumer of your API is forced into much more work.
On loading the JS client, remember some HTTP headers (user agent comes to mind) and the IP address and ask for reauthentication if they change, employing blacklists for the usual suspects. This forces an attacker to do his homework more thoroughly again.
On the server side, remember the last few API calls, and before allowing another one, check if business logic allows for the new one right now: This denies an attacker the ability to concentrate many of his sessions into one session with your server: In combination with the other measures, this will make an abuser easy detectable.
I might not have said that with the necessary clarity: I consider it impossible to make it completely impossible for an abuser to consume your service, but you can make it so hard, it might not be worth the hassle.
You should implement some sort of authentication system. One good way to handle this is to define some expected header variables. For example, you can have an auth/login API call that returns a session token. Subsequent calls to your API will expect a session token to be set in an HTTP header variable with a specific name like 'your-api-token'.
Alternatively many systems create access tokens or keys that are expected (like youtube, facebook or twitter) using some sort of api account system. In those cases, your client would have to store these in some manner in the client.
Then it's simply a matter of adding a check for the session into your REST framework and throwing an exception. If at all possible the status code (to be restful) would be a 401 error.
There's an open standard now called "JSON Web Token",
see https://jwt.io/ & https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/JSON_Web_Token
JSON Web Token (JWT) is a JSON-based open standard (RFC 7519) for
creating tokens that assert some number of claims. For example, a
server could generate a token that has the claim "logged in as admin"
and provide that to a client. The client could then use that token to
prove that they are logged in as admin. The tokens are signed by the
server's key, so the server is able to verify that the token is
legitimate. The tokens are designed to be compact, URL-safe and usable
especially in web browser single sign-on (SSO) context. JWT claims can
be typically used to pass identity of authenticated users between an
identity provider and a service provider, or any other type of claims
as required by business processes.[1][2] The tokens can also be
authenticated and encrypted.[3][4]
Set a SESSION var on the server when the client first loads your index.html (or backbone.js etc.)
Check this var on the server-side on every API call.
P.S. this is not a "security" solution!!! This is just to ease the load on your server so people don't abuse it or "hotlink" your API from other websites and apps.
Excuse me #MarkAmery and Eugene, but that is incorrect.
Your js+html (client) app running in the browser CAN be set up to exclude unauthorized direct calls to the API as follows:
First step: Set up the API to require authentication. The client must first authenticate itself via the server (or some other security server) for example asking the human user to provide the correct password.
Before authentication the calls to the API are not accepted.
During authentication a "token" is returned.
After authentication only API calls with the authentication "token" will be accepted.
Of course at this stage only authorized users who have the password can access the API, although if they are programmers debugging the app, they can access it directly for testing purposes.
Second step: Now set up an extra security API, that is to be called within a short limit of time after the client js+html app was initially requested from the server. This "callback" will tell the server that the client was downloaded successfully. Restrict your REST API calls to work only if the client was requested recently and successfully.
Now in order to use your API they must first download the client and actually run it in a browser. Only after successfully receiving the callback, and then user entry within a short frame of time, will the API accept calls.
So you do not have to worry that this may be an unauthorized user without credentials.
(The title of the question, 'How do I secure REST API calls', and from most of what you say, that is your major concern, and not the literal question of HOW your API is called, but rather BY WHOM, correct?)
Here's what I do:
Secure the API with an HTTP Header with calls such as X-APITOKEN:
Use session variables in PHP. Have a login system in place and save the user token in session variables.
Call JS code with Ajax to PHP and use the session variable with curl to call the API. That way, if the session variable is not set, it won't call and the PHP code contains the Access Token to the API.
I'm a back-end developer who has to create the front-end too in the current project!
I'm using reactJs and I know that for authorizing users I should get an api_token from my back-end API then use the api_token in the next requests! so I should store the api_token (actually somewhere into the client's browser)! but where should I store it to be secure?
the first answer came to my mind was 'Local Storage' ! but I've read this article: Don't store tokens in local storage
I've searched and found #auth0/auth0-spa-js, but I don't know can I trust this package (and similar) or not?
these are the way's which I've found! but what's the correct way to store sensitive data like this?
The Auth Flow should be on the Web should be
Send User/Password Details to server
Server validates and returns encrypted token with some details inside and that's stored as a HTTP Cookie
Setup Protected endpoints so only users with token can access them
Security : HTTP Cookie only means that the browser doesn't have access to it on the client, only the server. But someone can simply just Copy Paste it into their cookies which if you're worried about or working on sensitive stuff, you will need to implement additional security measures such as the ones mentioned.
Generally, Device Management is not a web concern but you can also some validation on the token for things like make the token expire in 5 minutes, or expire on session end, DeviceId, Browser Id, IP address, send them an email that a new unknown IP has logged in, etc.
Never store private tokens in your frontend code
You should create a server that can only be accessed from a particular url (the url of your app). This server can have the secret tokens that you need to make calls. The that server can forward requests to the services you will use that need private tokens.
I have developed a single page AngularJS application. For data retrieval/storage, it communicates with REST APIs over https. As per client requirement, i need to implement Client Authentication. i.e., As the application is based on REST APIs, how can we ensure that the request made to API is from a valid client and not from fiddler or a tempered client.
the current approach is:
1> configure a client secret and a key in the angular app.
2> authenticate the client by requesting a token from server using this client secret and key.
3> server checks this secret and key, if validates, responds with a newly generated token.
4> all further requests from angularjs app would carry this token in header, to ensure that the request is from a valid client.
But it is not good enough, as attacker can easily capture the requests using fiddler and also can easily read the client secret and key. or can debug using firebug.
Is there any secure way to authenticate the client app?
No security possible in the case if your REST API call is been shield by any User Authentication. I mean if User need to put Username/Password then they are able to call those API then you can implement some security.
But if your requirement like follows :
Any GUEST user with any browser open your application pages, which intern call your REST API.
Then there is no security. Since any attacker can intercept your Request/Response and call it further.
Note : From security prepective, Whatever a Browser can do, any good attacker can do the same.
But if you shield REST CALL Pages with username/password validation, then you can restrict the calls from server side with proper session validation.
JSON Web Tokens (JWT - pronounced jot) might be what you're looking for. Auth0 has a swell blog post that specifically addresses AngularJS + JWT.
You cannot trust the client to validate anything. If the user is using Firebug or Fiddler to "trick" your application then all you can do is verify the information server side to ensure it is valid.
You can trust the client to keep the user's session safe (to some extent), but if you can't trust the user then you can't trust anything the client sends to you.
If you need to ensure the integrity of a piece of data that is held client side you can use a MAC (Message Authentication Code) which is effectively a hash of the message appended to a server-side secret key that can be later verified. Sometimes this is (incorrectly) called signing. JWTs are the current standard to accomplish this.
It depends at the end of the day what threat you are trying to keep your application safe against - if it is a game with high scores that runs on the client, there's not much you can do to prevent the user from altering their score before it is sent to the server. If you need to trust such data, run it server side.
I'm designing a REST API and I've hit somewhat of an odd point. 99% of this API will be secured, but there are a few functions that need to be publicly accessible. These pertain to account creation, and initial password setting. Once they have credentials, they can access the rest of the API.
The endpoint that allows a user to create a new account via a signup form is unauthenticated. Securing this endpoint isn't really possible because I'm using AngularJS on top of nodejs, and dog-fooding my API via AJAX calls. This means I can't hide credentials anywhere to access the AccountCreation endpoint. Currently, I have the webform make an AJAX call to another endpoint and create a token that says to form is valid. Upon submission that token is validated, then removed from the database. However, this token endpoint is obviously visible in code, so not much security there. Email verification is used to 'activate' the account, then the user is given a one-time link to set their initial password, which also resides on an unauthenticated endpoint(but requires the token sent in the email).
I guess my worry is someone spamming the 'CreateAccount' endpoint, and making a bunch of accounts. In reality I guess they could simply do this via the webform as well. Is this a valid security concern? How do most places handle unauthenticated account creation webforms?
Edit: the final application will be run over https
I am writing an application in Google appengine python. Due to the limited support of the appengine environment I have to implement some of the functionality on external dedicated servers. Is there an authentication mechanism available that will preserve login information over the external servers and appengine.
The system you want should probably work something like this:
When a user visits the 'other' server with no session cookie set, the server redirects the user to a special URL on the App Engine app - let's use /authenticate - with a 'next' query string parameter that provides the URL of the next stage (described in #3).
When App Engine receives a request to /authenticate, it checks if the user is signed in there. If they're not, it prompts them to sign in. Then, it generates a token for the user's session, and signs it with an HMAC, using a secret shared by both servers, and redirects the user to the URL provided in step 1, with the HMAC included in the query string.
When the 'other' server receives a request to its special URL (specified in step #1), it validates that the HMAC matches, using the shared secret, and if it does, uses its own session support to set a cookie on the user's browser under its domain, to keep track of the user from then on.
If the 'other' server needs to obtain more information about the user, it can use an API it shares with the App Engine server to request, out-of-band, more information about the user using the token it was given and the shared secret.
This is very similar to the procedure OAuth uses, but entirely noninteractive for the user. It's also the procedure that SSO systems such as Google Accounts use to 'transfer' sessions to other trusted parties.