WPF Specifying HierarchicalDataTemplate for Interface - wpf

Question

I've found a really strange quirk in WPF. If I specify a DataTemplate for an interface, it will work if defined inside an ItemsControl.ItemTemplate, but will not work if defined inside ItemsControl.Resrouces.
Concrete example:
I have a tree structure I want to represent. All items in the tree implement IHardware, but they do not necessarily have a common base type. If I define a HierarchicalDataTemplate for IHardware inside TreeView.ItemTemplate, everything works swimmingly. If I define the template inside TreeView.Resources, it never gets used/applied. The following shows the same data in 2 columns, the first column works as expected, the second column does not.
<Window x:Class="WPFInterfaceBinding.MainWindow"
xmlns="http://schemas.microsoft.com/winfx/2006/xaml/presentation"
xmlns:x="http://schemas.microsoft.com/winfx/2006/xaml"
xmlns:self ="clr-namespace:WPFInterfaceBinding"
DataContext="{Binding RelativeSource={RelativeSource Self}}"
Title="MainWindow" Height="350" Width="525">
<Grid>
<Grid.ColumnDefinitions>
<ColumnDefinition />
<ColumnDefinition />
</Grid.ColumnDefinitions>
<!-- Works -->
<Border
Grid.Column="0"
Background="Gray">
<TreeView
ItemsSource="{Binding Hardware}">
<TreeView.ItemTemplate>
<HierarchicalDataTemplate
DataType="{x:Type self:IHardware}"
ItemsSource="{Binding SubHardware}">
<TextBlock Text="{Binding Path=Name}" />
</HierarchicalDataTemplate>
</TreeView.ItemTemplate>
</TreeView>
</Border>
<!-- Doesn't work -->
<Border
Grid.Column="1"
Background="Gray">
<TreeView
ItemsSource="{Binding Hardware}">
<TreeView.Resources>
<HierarchicalDataTemplate
DataType="{x:Type self:IHardware}"
ItemsSource="{Binding SubHardware}">
<TextBlock Text="{Binding Path=Name}" />
</HierarchicalDataTemplate>
</TreeView.Resources>
</TreeView>
</Border>
</Grid>
</Window>
Note that in the second column, nothing has changed except TreeView.ItemTemplate -> TreeView.Resources
Why is this the case? How can I get the template to work when inside Resources? I imagine I can work around this using a DataTemplateSelector, but first I'm curious if there's a way to actually get it working as expected.
Code behind, for completeness
using System.Windows;
namespace WPFInterfaceBinding
{
public partial class MainWindow : Window
{
public IHardware[] Hardware { get; private set; }
public MainWindow ()
{
Hardware = InitializeHardware();
InitializeComponent();
}
private IHardware[] InitializeHardware ()
{
return new Hardware[] {
new Hardware("Component 1", new Hardware[] {
new Hardware("Sub Component 1"),
new Hardware("Sub Component 2")
}),
new Hardware("Component 2", new Hardware[] {
new Hardware("Sub Component 3"),
new Hardware("Sub Component 4")
})
};
}
}
public class Hardware : IHardware
{
public string Name { get; set; }
public IHardware[] SubHardware { get; set; }
public Hardware ( string name, Hardware[] subHardware = null )
{
Name = name;
SubHardware = subHardware ?? new Hardware[0];
}
}
public interface IHardware
{
string Name { get; set; }
IHardware[] SubHardware { get; set; }
}
}
Additional information:
I can't simply use ItemTemplate because in my actual usage scenario there will be non-IHardware items mixed in using a CompositeCollection so I need multiple templates.
I can't change the types of the collections from IHardware to something concrete because I'm displaying data from code I don't control.
This is just example code, not representative of any design patterns actually in use.
Defining the template inside TreeView.Resources works just fine if the type is changed from IHardware to Hardware.

Answer 1

Turns out, WPF just doesn't like binding to interfaces. The only work around I could figure out was to use a DataTemplateSelector.
public class OHMTreeTemplateSelector : DataTemplateSelector
{
public HierarchicalDataTemplate HardwareTemplate { get; set; }
public DataTemplate SensorTemplate { get; set; }
public override DataTemplate SelectTemplate ( object item, DependencyObject container )
{
if ( item is IHardware ) return HardwareTemplate;
else if ( item is ISensor ) return SensorTemplate;
return base.SelectTemplate(item, container);
}
}
Though, for other reasons I ended up creating a separate ViewModel for the data that exposes it through concrete types, circumventing this issue.