Saving data with HABTM and HasMany looses foreignKey - cakephp

Question

I have a User model with two relations:
HasAndBelongsToMany
public $hasAndBelongsToMany = array(
'group' => array(
'className' => 'group',
'foreignKey' => 'user_id'
)
);
HasMany
public $hasMany = array(
'phonenumber' => array(
'className' => 'phonenumber',
'foreignKey' => 'user_id'
)
);
Phonenumber and Group have set
public $belongsTo = array(
'User' => array(
'className' => 'User',
'foreignKey' => 'user_id'
)
);
When I use
$this->saveAll(array(
'User' => $data,
'phonenumber' => $numbers, //array with data
'group' => $groups //array with data
)
);
The data gets saved in the tabels but User_id is "0" in phonenumber and group table.
How can I get the correct ID saved ? (CakePHP v 2.5)

Answer 1

FWIW saveAll() should work as advertised, populating the new user_id in the child tables in one fell swoop.
Have you paid attention to the relevant options: atomic & deep?
Especially if database does not support transactions, you'll need to pass in atomic:
$this->saveAll(array(
'User' => $data,
'phonenumber' => $numbers, //array with data
'group' => $groups //array with data
),
array('atomic' => false)
);

Answer 2

Considering the CakePHP documentation you will find this hint:
When working with associated models, it is important to realize that
saving model data should always be done by the corresponding CakePHP
model. If you are saving a new Post and its associated Comments, then
you would use both Post and Comment models during the save operation
(http://book.cakephp.org/2.0/en/models/saving-your-data.html#saving-related-model-data-hasone-hasmany-belongsto)
Based on that information I suggest you try the following:
$this->User->save($data); // first save the user
Assuming you have multiple numbers:
foreach($numbers as $key => $nbr) {
// set user_id related data
$numbers[ $key ]['Phonenumber']['user_id'] = $this->User->id;
}
Finally save your related data:
$this->User->Phonenumber->saveAll($numbers);
Since this code is untested you may need to take some adjustments. Always ensure to follow the Cake-Conventions and use CamelCase ModelNames.