How to use scanf for a char array input? - c

I set a char array of size of 10 and want to check the real size of the input permitted.
I tested
123456789; 1234567890; 123456789123456789
Interestingly, all of them passed and got the right output which are
123456789; 1234567890; 123456789123456789
It confused me a lot because I thought the last two are wrong input.
Does that make sense or is it a compiler difference?
This is the code
#include <stdio.h>
main()
{
char input[10];
scanf("%s", input);
printf(input);
} '

The scanf() with format specifier %s scans the input until a space is encountered. In your case, what you are seeing is undefined behavior.
Your array can hold 10 chars, but you are writing out of its boundaries.
While you are getting an expected answer now, this is not always guarnateed and may instead cause a crash.
It is advisable to use a function such as fgets() takes care of buffer overflow.

You can use
scanf("%9s", input);

Related

Why is the output 6487620 (profit) by giving any input in this c program used to show profit or loss [duplicate]

#include <stdio.h>
#include <stdlib.h>
int main() {
char a;
printf("What? \t");
scanf("%s", &a);
printf("U have to %s", a);
return 0;
}
Whenever I build and run this code and enter a value in %s, I get an error and the debug program stops working and closes. But when I use ampersand sign like this:
#include <stdio.h>
#include <stdlib.h>
int main() {
char a;
printf("What? \t");
scanf("%s", &a);
printf("U have to %s", &a);
return 0;
}
in the printf... it works. Why is that? It also differs between the format specifier, such as one doesn't need to put & (ampersand) sign in printf when one uses %c or %d in the scanf. Why does this happen and is it related to the data types and which format specifiers concludes this result?
(sorry for my bad English. I am not a native English speaker and this is my first time here).
What you have here is a classic example of code that seems to work, but for the wrong reasons.
Let's review a few things about printf and scanf. The format specifier %d is for values of type int. You can read an integer like this:
int i;
scanf("%d", &i);
And you can print it back out like this:
printf("%d\n", i);
Why does one use an & and one does not? Well, C uses what's called "pass by value". If we wrote
scanf("%d", i); /* WRONG */
we would be passing the value of i to scanf. But we don't want to pass the (old) value of i to scanf, we want scanf to read a new value, and store it into i. In other words, we want scanf to, in effect, pass the new value of i back to us. For that to work, we instead pass scanf a pointer to the variable i where we want it to store the just-read integer. That's what the & does -- it generates a pointer to i.
When we call printf, on the other hand, the regular way of passing arguments works just fine. We do want to pass i's value to printf so that it can print it out. If we were to call
printf("%d\n", &i); /* WRONG */
it wouldn't work, because printf expects an int, and here we're wrongly handing it a pointer-to-int.
So now we've learned that for integers with %d, printf wants an int and scanf wants a pointer-to-int.
Let's talk about characters. The format %c is for characters. We can read one character with scanf:
char c;
scanf("%c", &c);
And we can print it with printf:
printf("%c\n", c);
Again, the pattern is exactly the same. scanf needs a pointer, so that it can fill in the value, so we pass &c. But printf just needs the value, so we pass plain c.
Now we get to strings. A string in C is an array of characters. Also strings in C are always terminated by a special null character, '\0', that marks the end of the string. So if we wanted to declare a variable that could contain strings up to 9 characters long, we might write
char s[10];
That gives us room for 9 characters, plus the terminating '\0'.
But arrays are special in C: Whenever you pass an array to a function, or whenever you do anything that would require the "value" of the array, what you get instead (what the compiler automatically generates for you) is a pointer to the array's first element.
What this means is that to read a string with scanf and %s, we can just call:
scanf("%s", s);
"But where is the &?", you ask. "I thought you always needed an & when calling scanf!"
Well, not quite. You always need a pointer when calling scanf. And in fact, when you called scanf("%s", s), it was just as if you had written
scanf("%s", &s[0]);
When you use %s with scanf, it expects a pointer to the first of several characters, that is, a pointer to the beginning of an array of characters, where it should begin writing the string it reads. (How does it know how big the array is? What if the user types a string that's too long to fit in the array? We'll get to those points in a moment.)
You can print strings with %s too, of course, and it looks like this:
printf("%s\n", s);
This is, again, just as if you had written
printf("%s\n", &s[0]);
When you use %s with printf, it expects a pointer to the first of several characters which it should begin printing, until it finds the terminating '\0' character.
So %s is special with printf and scanf, because strings are special (because arrays are special). With %d and %c and just about every other format specifier, you usually need a & when you call scanf, and you usually don't want that & when you call printf. But with %s, you usually don't want the & for either printf or scanf.
(And if we think about it a bit more carefully, the exception is not so much that scanf and %s does not need the &. Remember, the rule is really, scanf always needs pointers. The only reason scanf and %s doesn't need an & is that when you pass an array, you get a pointer to the array's first element automatically. So the exception is really for printf and %s: printf and %s does expect a pointer, and the reason printf and %s is designed to expect a pointer is that there's no way to not give it one: it has to accept a pointer, because for strings, that's what you always end up giving it.)
So the rule with %s is that scanf expects a pointer to the first of several characters, and printf expects a pointer to the first of several characters, too.
So now, with all that background out of the way, we can look at your code. You basically wrote
char c;
scanf("%s", &c);
At first this might seem to be kinda, sorta, almost correct. scanf and %s wants a pointer to a character, and you gave it &c, which is a pointer to a character. But %s really wants a pointer to the first of several characters. But you gave it a pointer to just a single character. So when the user types a string, the first character typed will get stored in c, but the rest of the characters, and the terminating '\0', will get written to unallocated memory somewhere off to the right of variable c. They'll overwrite ("clobber") memory that was, perhaps, used for something else. This is a serious problem, but it might not become evident right away.
Finally, you tried to print things out again with printf. You first tried
printf("%s\n", c); /* WRONG */
but this didn't work at all. The reason is that %s with printf expects a pointer-to-char, but you gave it a plain char. Suppose c contains the letter 'A'. This would end up asking printf to go to address 65 and begin printing characters until it finds the terminating '\0'. Why address 65? Because 65 is the ASCII code for A. But there's probably not a proper, null-terminated string starting at address 65 in memory; in fact there's a good chance your program doesn't have permission to read from address 65 at all.
So then you tried
printf("%s\n", &c); /* ALSO WRONG */
and this seemed to work. It "worked" because, if scanf succeeded in storing a complete string into c and the unallocated memory off to the right of it, and if clobbering that memory somehow didn't cause (too many) other problems, then when you pass the pointer &c to printf, printf can find those characters, making up a string, and print them out.
So it "works", but as I said, for the wrong reasons: in the process it stomps all over memory it doesn't "own", and sooner or later, something else is going to not work as a result.
How should you have scanned and printed a string? One way is like this, as we saw before:
char s[10];
scanf("%s", s);
printf("%s\n", s);
Now when scanf gets a pointer to the first element of the array s, it has 10 characters to play with.
We really do have to worry about the possibility that the user will type more than 9 characters. But there's a fix for that: we can tell scanf how long a string it's allowed to read, how many characters it's allowed to write to the array we handed it:
scanf("%9s", s);
That 9 in there tells scanf that it's not allowed to read more than 9 characters from the user. And since 9 is less than 10, there's still room for the terminating '\0' character.
There's much more that could be said about scanf. As chqrlie noted in a comment, it's important to check its return value, to make sure it succeeded in converting as many values as you wanted it to. It's got some strange rules about whitespace. Unless you know what you're doing, you can't intermix calls to scanf with calls to other input-reading functions like getchar or fgets -- you'll get strange results. And, finally, scanf is so persnickety and (in the end) so lacking in truly useful functionality that it's not really worth using at all. But those are topics for another day, since this answer is tl;dr already.
The %s format specifier requires a pointer to a string. When used with scanf, it must be a char array with enough characters for the word you enter plus the trailing null byte that indicates the end of the string. In printf() it has to be a null-terminated char array.
Using a pointer to a char variable doesn't work, because it doesn't have room for the null byte. You're causing undefined behavior by writing outside the variable.
char word[100];
scanf("%s", word);
printf("%s\n", word);
You can use %c to read and write a single character rather than a string of multiple characters.
char letter;
scanf("%c", &letter);
printf("%c\n", letter);
In statement char a; a is a character variable & to scan a char variable use %c format specifier.
scanf("%s",a);/* %s expects base address of char buffer, not single char */
scanf(" %c",&a);/* this is correct */
If you want to scan using %s then your input should be char buffer like char buf[10]. for e.g
char a[10];
scanf("%s",a);
u don't need to put &(ampersand) sign in printf when u use %c or %d ? no need to provide address & to printf() as printf() job is to print not to scan. for e.g
char input;
scanf("%c",&input);/* here you need &, As scanf() will store input char into
address you provided i.e &input */
printf("%c",input);/*here no need &input, bcz input char already stored,
printf will just print the char*/
Well, if you print the address you can use %p.
printf("%p",a);/*a is char buffer */

Comparing two strings in C in a loop

I am writing a code to see whether or not the user's input is equivalent to an already stated string. The program loops until the input is the same as the string, using the strcmp function, but for some reason the program does not compare the strings and therefore the loop malfunctions. The code is below:
int main()
{
char passcode[3]="ZZZ";
char input[3];
int check;
while(check!=0)
{
printf("What is the password?\n");
gets(input);
check=strcmp(passcode, input);
}
printf("You crack the pass code!");
return 0;
}
The main problem is here:
char passcode[3]="ZZZ";
char input[3];
A string in C consists of a sequence of characters followed by a null byte. passcode is not large enough to hold the null byte for the string it's initialized with. So when you try to use it as a string by passing it to strcmp it reads past the end of the array. Doing so invokes undefined behavior.
Similarly, input isn't big enough to hold a string big enough to compare against.
You're also not initializing check, so the first time you enter the loop it's value is unknown.
Another problem is the use of gets. This function is dangerous because it does not check if the string the user entered can fit into the given buffer. If is is too big, this again invokes undefined behavior.
Make your arrays larger to hold the user's input as well as the target string, and use fgets instead of gets. You should also change the while loop to do..while since you need to enter the loop at least once.
#include <stdio.h>
int main()
{
char passcode[]="ZZZ"; // array is automatically sized
char input[50];
int check;
do {
printf("What is the password?\n");
fgets(input, sizeof(input), stdin);
check=strcmp(passcode, input);
} while (check!=0);
printf("You crack the pass code!");
return 0;
}
The suggested code above does not recognize the input. It likely wont work and will stuck within the while loop. I would suggest to make it much easier using scanf for the input and then compare the string as you did with strcmp. If input is correct then let in and break out of the while loop. Try this:
#include <stdio.h>
int main()
{
char input[3];
printf ("\nHit the pass code!\npass code: ");
while (input != "ZZZ") {
scanf ("%s",&input);
if (strcmp(input, "ZZZ") == 0){
printf ("\nYou crack the pass code!!\n\n");
break;
} else {
printf ("Wroooong!\n pass code: ");
}
}
return 0;
}
I see what is going on. Your input string is only three three bytes and you are reading using the unsafe gets. The gets is putting the input of ZZZ into the input variable as expected but it is putting the terminating null in the first byte of passcode.
Change the size of your input buffer to 999 and things will work a lot better.

c - scanf not storing input properly

My code looks like this:
int nameFull;
printf("What is your name?\n");
scanf("%d\n", &nameFull); \\up until here it seems to work
printf("Hello %d", nameFull);
return 0;
But my output every time I run the program is "Hello 0" no matter what I input.
Does anyone know how to fix this?
First of all scanf() doesn't emit a prompt so its not a good idea to use any trailing whitespace character in the format string like \n here , It will cause it to read and discard character until next non-whitespace character.
To read a name you can do it like :
char name[50];
scanf("%49s",name); // 49 to limit the buffer input to prevent buffer overrun , this is a security issue.
You should also check the return value of scanf to see if the operation was successful. Personally , I don't prefer using scanf() at all because of various potential problems. It takes as input only what the program author expects it to, not considering other inputs which user might accidentally input. Check out here and here. Also check the scanf() man page
A better and safer method would be use fgets(),
fgets(name,sizeof(name),stdin);
You want to read a string, but you are an integer to store the input. That's not the right approach.
A better aproach would be to use an array of characters, to store the string in it.
char nameFull[100]; // can store up to 100 characters, 99 + 1 for the null-terminator ideally
Now, you could use scanf, like this:
scanf(" %99[^\n]", nameFull);
Note that I used 99, as a guard for not overflowing your array nameFull, if the user inputs too many characters for the size of your array. I didn't use %s, which would stop at a whitespace, and you seem to want to input a full name, which is usually two words and a space in between.
An alternative would be to use fgets(), which provides more safety, like this:
fgets(nameFull, sizeof(nameFull), stdin)
It will read the whole line though and store the trailing newline, while scanf() will read a single string.
Moreover, use the string identifier to print, not the integer one (%s is for string, %d is for integers). Like this:
printf("Hello %d", nameFull);
to this:
printf("Hello %s", nameFull);
as discussed about the string format.
%s reads a string of characters.
%d reads a integer.
So, your correct code will be like following code :
#include <stdio.h>
int main(){
char nameFull[100];
printf("What is your name?\n");
scanf("%99s", nameFull); //to avoid potential buffer overflow
printf("Hello %s\n", nameFull);
return 0;
}
N.B: Check this comment for nice explanation.
Well, int stores a number, a name is not a number. A name is a set of characters (aka strings). So this program would work (no error checking and such since you are in an introductory course):
char name[1024]; // 1024 is more than enough space for a name
scanf("%s", name); // %s reads a string of characters
printf("Hello %s\n", name);
return 0;
You are trying to assign an array of character (commonly referred as string) to an integer variable.
That's not correct.
Just change your variable as such
char nameFull[1024] = {0};
And then use scanf(3) with the appropriate format specifiers for strings, which is %s
scanf("%s", nameFull);
Normally you would check for the return of scanf to know if errors occurs, and in such cases, handle them.
Anyway, I would advice you to use fgets(3) which prevents buffer overflow
char *fgets(char *s, int size, FILE *stream);
fgets() reads in at most one less than size characters from stream and stores them into the buffer pointed to by s. Reading stops after an EOF or a newline. If a newline is read, it is stored into the buffer. A terminating null byte (aq\0aq) is stored after the last character in the buffer.

C - strcmp won't work with scanf()

I am trying to use scanf() with strcmp. However, it doesn't work. I've included the right header files. I've tried out gets(). It works but I don't want to be vulnerable of a buffer overflow attack.
#include<stdio.h>
#include<stdlib.h>
#include<string.h>
int main() {
char a[100] = "Hello World!";
char b[100];
scanf("%s", &b);
if(strcmp(a, b) == 0) {
printf("This should work!\n");
}
}
I compile the program. Then, type Hello World! into the program. It won't show the message. Also, why does strcmp() show me all kinds of return values?
Please help.
Reading the manual on scanf -- you will see that it stops scanning a %s at the first whitespace found
scanf("%s", b);
of
Hello World
will give you Hello but not Wolrd
Also note that scanf is equally vulnerable to buffer overflow, as you are still not limiting the size of the input in %s -- to limit the input you should probably try to do %99s making sure that you are not reading more than your 100 byte buffer still leavng space for your null termination.
As per this question you need something like
scanf("%[^\n]",str)
to read everything up to the newline, and combining that with a length restrction, you would need something like
scanf("%99[^\n]",str)

How do I get the user to input a word for string comparison?

I'm running a while loop so the user can constantly enter expressions, until they indicate they want to quit the program. I'm using strcmp() to compare two strings so as soon as they enter quit the program will stop. But the program keeps going, any Ideas?
#include <stdio.h>
#include <string.h>
int main()
{
int min12=0;
char opper;
int x=0;
int min13;
char *Repeatprog="cont";
char *Repeatprog1="quit";
while (strcmp(Repeatprog,Repeatprog1))
{
printf("enter the integer number \n");
scanf( "%d %c %d", &min12, &opper, &min13);
printf("%d %c %d\n", min12, opper, min13);
printf("Type the word quit to end program\n");
scanf("%s", Repeatprog);
}
printf("Good Bye");
return 0;
}
Remember always that an Array is a Pointer to the first object of the array.
And secondly, in your call to scanf() you only read a character. Not a whole string (represented by %s in C)
So in conclusion, your call to scanf() shouldn't have a pointer and should have a string instead of a character.
scanf("%s", Repeatprog);
or simply
gets (Repeatprog);
EDIT :
As the commenter #EOF said, gets() is not a good idea since it can lead to Undefined Behaviour. That's because the program can read more characters than it should have and lead to overflow, thus it isn't secure.
So I recommend using char *fgets(char *str, int n, FILE *stream)
Note:
Also, your code is using string literals. So if you make any attempt to change the content of the char pointer then it will lead to Undefined Behaviour.
For this note, please thank the guys below me [comments]. I made a huge mistake and I'm sorry.

Resources