Makefile dependencies on multiple files - c

Question

I have created a Makefile for unit tests which uses GCC with arguments to create profiling files (gcno) during compiling. Here's a similified part of it where compiling and linking takes place:
UTEXE = $(UTOBJSDIR)\$(UTUNIT).exe
UTOBJS = $(UTUUTSRC:.c=.o) $(UTUTSRC:.c=.o) $(UTCSRC:.c=.o)
UTOBJSFULL = $(addprefix $(UTOBJSDIR)\,$(UTOBJS))
UTOBJSGCNO = $(addprefix $(UTOBJSDIR)\,$(UTOBJS:.o=.gcno))
$(UTOBJS): %.o: %.c $(UTMAKEDEP)
$(call report,Compiling $(*F).c)
$(MKDEP) $(MKDFLAGS) -o.o -f$(UTOBJSDIR)\$(*F).dep $(subst /,\,$<)
$(CC) -c $(CFLAGS) $(subst /,\,$<) -o $(UTOBJSDIR)/$#
$(UTOBJSGCNO): $(UTOBJS) $(UTMAKEDEP)
utbuild: $(UTEXE) $(UTOBJSGCNO) $(UTOBJS) $(UTMAKEDEP)
$(UTEXE): $(UTOBJSGCNO) $(UTOBJS) $(UTMAKEDEP)
$(call report,Linking to $(UTUNIT).exe)
$(LINK) $(UTOBJSFULL) $(LNKFLAGS) -o $(UTEXE)
It compiles all the object and profile files and links together a binary. However when i delete some profile file (gcno) and call "utbuild" again it won't re-compile to restore the .gcno file. It tries to do linking again because gcno is a prequisite to it, but it wont do the compiling.
I don't know how to name this case so couldn't find solution from internet. Basically one recipe creates two files and i don't know how to write the rule that re-run's recipe even when only one file needs to re-created.
I would appreciate some links or hints.

Answer 1

thanks for all the comments. I've tried no-op ";" and ":=" with same outcome.
I think i need to take one step back and explain why i asked this question. It's not just about deleting or not-deleting gcno files manually, it's about general understanding how to write such a Makefile which restores any missing or out-of-date file. My Makefile has similar cases in few places and it's using parallel build so when some file goes missing it gives lot of weird errors. Usually it's solved by "clean" and "all", but i'd like the Makefile to be perfect and handle the missing file issues nicely.
As the example above is not so clear without all the rest of the Makefile then i made a new simple test.
hello.c
#include <stdio.h>
int main()
{
printf("Hello world\n");
}
Makefile
CCDIR = C:\tools\MinGW
CCBINDIR = $(CCDIR)\bin
CCINCDIR = $(CCDIR)\include;$(CCDIR)\lib\gcc\mingw32\4.8.1\include
CCLIBDIR = $(CCDIR)\lib;$(CCDIR)\lib\gcc\mingw32\4.8.1
# Overcome "missing dll file" messages on Windows
CC = set PATH=%PATH%;$(CCBINDIR)& $(CCBINDIR)\gcc.exe
LINK = set PATH=%PATH%;$(CCBINDIR)& $(CCBINDIR)\gcc.exe
# Compile and link for code coverage
CFLAGS = -fprofile-arcs -ftest-coverage -g3 -O0 $(addprefix -I,$(CCINCDIR))
LNKFLAGS = -fprofile-arcs -ftest-coverage -static -static-libgcc $(addprefix -L,$(CCLIBDIR))
OBJECTS = hello.o
EXE = hello.exe
$(OBJECTS): %.o: %.c
$(CC) -c $(CFLAGS) $(subst /,\,$<) -o $#
$(EXE): $(OBJECTS)
$(LINK) $(OBJECTS) $(LNKFLAGS) -o $(EXE)
build: $(EXE)
"make build" creates following files:
hello.o
hello.gcno
hello.exe
Now if i delete the "hello.gcno" and run build again it tells me:
mingw32-make: Nothing to be done for 'build'.
The goal is to update Makefile so that the make re-creates the "hello.gcno". It would probably re-create "hello.o" and "hello.exe" also during that process but that's not a problem.
Edit:
Just to be clear: in real Makefile i really-really need the .gcno files. It's not just an additional information or something which to avoid or do optionally. The Makefile builds the unit test executables, runs them and executes gcov to generate code coverage information and gcovr creates a report of all the .gcov files. If .gcno file is missing it won't work. Also - as it's parallel build then dependencies shall be absolutely correct to avoid some process starting earlier and it's tricky because coverage report has dependencies coming from two "branches" - .gcno files from compile stage and .gcda files from execute stage. So that's why i need it to be correct.

Answer 2

your only option here is this :
(if you can change the rule)
$(EXE): $(OBJECTS)
$(LINK) $(OBJECTS) $(LNKFLAGS) -o $(EXE)
to this:
%.exe %.gnco: $(OBJECTS)
$(LINK) $(OBJECTS) $(LNKFLAGS) -o $(EXE)
$(GENERATE_GNCO) $<

Answer 3

Here is a very simple solution of one thing dependig on two other things
compile:./src/main.c ./src/error.c
gcc ./src/error.c ./src/main.c -o ./exe/calc
run : ./exe/calc
./exe/calc

Answer 4

The correct answer in my opinion, is, don't delete any .gcno files by themselves. If you have to "clean", use make clean, but don't just go about deleting files.
The "build" is a state machine, with all the files constituting a "state". Don't corrupt the state!
Some people say, one should be able to delete arbitrary files and the build should recover. My answer is, what about if you corrupt some .o file by hand, say, add some 0's and 1's, making it unusable (thank you user3629249 for pointing that needs to be clarified, that I am talking about corruption, not intentional editing). Should the build also recover from that? Obviously no - no build system in the world will recover if you touch the .o file this way. Then why allow deleting a file, but not allow modifying it?? Where do you draw the line?
Simply put, any corruption should not be allowed. Use make clean only, or better yet, write your Makefile properly, so you never need to clean period.
The whole Makefile has a number of problems, here is how it should look like (I am assuming this is on Windows/DOS):
.SUFFIXES:
UTEXE := $(UTOBJSDIR)\$(UTUNIT).exe
UTOBJSFULL := $(addprefix $(UTOBJSDIR)\,$(subst /,\, $(UTUUTSRC:.c=.o) $(UTUTSRC:.c=.o) $(UTCSRC:.c=.o)))
UTOBJSGCNO := $(UTOBJSFULL:.o=.gcno)
.PHONY: utbuild all
all: utbuild
utbuild: $(UTEXE) $(UTOBJSGCNO) $(UTMAKEDEP)
$(UTOBJSGCNO): %.gcno: %.o $(UTMAKEDEP) ;
.SECONDARY: %\.
%\.: Makefile
mkdir $*
.SECONDEXPANSION:
$(UTOBJSFULL): $(UTOBJSDIR)\%.o: %.c $(UTMAKEDEP) | $$(#D)\.
$(call report,Compiling $<)
$(MKDEP) $(MKDFLAGS) -o.o -f$(UTOBJSDIR)\$(*F).dep $<
$(CC) -c $(CFLAGS) $< -o $#
$(UTEXE): $(UTOBJSFULL) $(UTMAKEDEP) | $$(#D)\.
$(call report,Linking to $(#F))
$(LINK) $(UTOBJSFULL) $(LNKFLAGS) -o $#