We are trying to implement a very interesting search logic with custom boosting and I am wondering if Solr can support this.
We have the following fields in our index:
Name
Description
Keywords (array)
Each keyword will have an amount(int value) paired to it.
A search is run across Name, description and keywords field. If a keyword matches the search text, the corresponding index must be boosted based on the amount of the matching keyword only.
I've read through Solr DisMax and they can only boost a field using a fixed amount.
My scenario will be to boost the result by X amount based on matching keywords only.
Thanks in advance
The only viable solution i see to this problem (assuming ofcourse you DO NOT know the number of keywords in advance) would be to just make the query as a filter query (to skip the scoring stage), get all documents matching ( a bit problematic), then just sort them on your side using the matched term to build the a java Comparator.
Problems may arise when you get a particularly large number of documents, but you could probably side step this issue by pagination
If you don't have too much different amounts maybe you can try this on index-time:
Store "keywords" in different fields(dynamicfields->boost-*) based on it's amount:
boost-1 = keyword1,keyword4,keyword6 <br/>
boost-10 = keyword2<br/>
boost-100 = keyword5
You can search across all your boost fields(edismax), boost every dynamicfield with his amount in your (e)dismax conf(boost-1^1,boost-10^10,boost-100^100).
Related
I am trying to do a product search setup using Solr. It does return results for keywords that follow the same order in the product name. However, when the keywords are mixed up, no results are returned. I would like to get results with scores that closely match the given keywords in any order.
My question on scoring has the schema, data configuration and query. Any help will be greatly appreciated.
As long as you enter your query as a regular query, instead of using wildcards, any hits in a text_general field as you've defined should be returned.
You can use the mm parameter to adjust how many of the terms supplied that need to match from a query. I suggest using the edismax query parser, as that allows you do to more "natural" queries instead of having to add the fieldnames in the query itself:
defType=edismax&qf=catchall&q=nikon dslr
defType=edismax&qf=catchall&q=dslr nikon
should both give the same set of documents (but possibly different scores when using phrase boosts).
I'm looking into the possibility of de-boosting a set of documents during
query time. In my application, when I search for e.g. "preferences", I want
to de-boost content tagged with ContentGroup:"Developer" or in other words,
push those content back in the order. Here's the catch. I've the following
weights on query fields and boost query on source
qf=text^6 title^15 IndexTerm^8
As you can see, title has a higher weight.
Now, a bunch of content tagged with ContentGroup:"Developer" consists of a
title like "Preferences.material" or "Preferences Property" or
"Preferences.graphics". The boost on title pushes these documents at the
top.
What I'm looking is to see if there's a way to deboost all documents that are
tagged with ContentGroup:"Developer" irrespective of the term occurrence is
text or title. I tried something like, but didn't make any difference.
Source:simplecontent^10 Source:Help^20 (-ContentGroup-local:("Developer"))^99
I'm using edismax query parser.
Any pointers will be appreciated.
Thanks,
Shamik
You're onto something with your last attempt, but you have to start with *:*, so that you actually have something to subtract the documents from. The resulting set of documents (those not matching your query) can then be boosted.
From the Solr Relevancy FAQ
How do I give a negative (or very low) boost to documents that match a query?
True negative boosts are not supported, but you can use a very "low" numeric boost value on query clauses. In general the problem that confuses people is that a "low" boost is still a boost, it can only improve the score of documents that match. For example, if you want to find all docs matching "foo" or "bar" but penalize the scores of documents matching "xxx" you might be tempted to try...
q = foo^100 bar^100 xxx^0.00001 # NOT WHAT YOU WANT
...but this will still help a document matching all three clauses score higher then a document matching only the first two. One way to fake a "negative boost" is to give a large boost to everything that does not match. For example...
q = foo^100 bar^100 (*:* -xxx)^999
NOTE: When using (e)dismax, people sometimes expect that specifying a pure negative query with a large boost in the "bq" param will work (since Solr automatically makes top level purely negative positive queries by adding an implicit ":" -- but this doesn't work with "bq", because of how queries specified via "bq" are added directly to the main query. You need to be explicit...
?defType=dismax&q=foo bar&bq=(*:* -xxx)^999
I implementing Solr search using an API. When I call it using the parameters as, "Chillout Lounge", it returns me the collection which are same/similar to the string "Chillout Lounge".
But when I search for "Chillout Lounge Box", it returns me results which don't have any of these three words.(in the DB there are values which have these 3 values, but they are not returned.)
According to me, Solr uses Fuzzy search, but when it is done it should return me some values, which will have at least one these value.
Or what could be the possible changes I should to my schema.XML, such that is would give me proper values.
First of all - "Fuzzy search" is a feature you'll have to ask for (by using ~ in standard Lucene query syntax).
If you're talking about regular searches, you can use q.op to select which operator to use. q.op=AND will make sure that all the terms match, while q.op=OR will make any document that contain at least one of the terms be returned. As long as you aren't using fq for this, the documents that match more terms should be scored higher (as the score will add up across multiple terms), and thus, be shown higher in the result set.
You can use the debug query feature in the web interface to see scores for each term for a document, and find out why the document was returned at all. If the document doesn't match any terms, it shouldn't be returned, unless you're asking for all documents to be returned.
Be aware that the analyzer chain defined for the field you're searching might affect what's considered a match and not.
You'll have to add a proper example to get a more detailed answer.
I'm using Solr 5.x, standard highlighter, and i'm getting snippets which matches even one of the search terms only, even if i indicate q.op=AND.
I need ONLY the fields and snippets that matches ALL the terms (unless i say q.op=OR or just omit it), i.e. the field/snippet must satisfy the query. Solr does return the field/snippet that has all the terms, but also return many others.
I'm using hl.fl=*, to get the only fields having the terms, and searching against the default field ('text' containing full doc). Need to use * since i have multiple dynamic fields. Most fields are 'text_general' type (for search and HL), and some are 'string' type for faceting.
If its not possible for snippets to have all the terms, i MUST get only the fields that satisfy the query fully (since the question is more talking about matching all the terms, but the search query can become arbitrarily complex, so the fields/snippets should match the query).
Also, next is to get snippets highlighted with proximity based search/terms. What should i do/use for this? The fields coming in highlighting in this scenario should also satisfy the proximity query (unlike i get a field that contain any term, without regard to proximity constrains and other query terms etc)
Thanks for your help.
I've also encountered the same problem with highlighting. In my case, the query like
(foo AND bar) OR eggs
highlighted eggs and foo despite bar was not present in the document. I didn't manage to come up with proper solution, however I devised a dirty workaround.
I use the following query:
id:highlighted_document_id AND text:(my_original_query)
with debugQuery set to true. Then I parse explain text for highlighted_document_id. The text contains the terms from the query, which have contributed to the score. The terms, which should not be highlighted, are not present in the explanation.
The Python regex expressions I use to extract the terms (valid for Solr 5.2.1):
term_regex = re.compile(r'weight\(text:(.+) in')
wildcard_term_regex = re.compile(r'text:(.+), product')
then I simply search the markings in the highlighted text and remove them if the term doesn't match against any of the term in term_regex and wildcard_term_regex.
The solution is probably pretty limited, but works for me.
Is it possible to boost a document on the indexing stage depending on the field value?
I'm indexing a text field pulled from the database. I would like to boost results that are shorter over the longer ones. So the value of boost should depend on the length of the text field.
This is needed to alter the standard SOLR behavior that in my case tends to return documents with multiple matches first.
Considering I have a field that stores the length of the document, the equivalent in the query of what I need at indexing would be:
q={!boost b=sqrt(length)}text:abcd
Example:
I have two items in the DB:
ABCDEBCE
ABCD
I always want to get ABCD first for the 'BC' query even though the other item contains the search query twice.
The other solution to the problem would be ability to 'switch off' the feature that scores multiple matches higher at query time. Don't know if that is possible either...
Doing this at index time is important as the hardware I run the SOLR on is not too powerful and trying to boost on query time returns with OutOfMemory Exception. (Even If I could work around that increasing memory for java I prefer to be on the safe side and implement the index the most efficient way possible.)
Yes and no - but how you do it depends on how you're indexing your documents.
As far as I know there's no way of resolving this only on the solr server side at the moment.
If you're using the regular XML based interface to submit documents, let the code that generates the submitted XML add boost=".." values to the field or to the document depending on the length of the text field.
You can check upon DIH Special Commands which has a $docBoost command
$docBoost : Boost the current doc. The value can be a number or the
toString of a number
However, there seems no $fieldBoost Command.
For you case though, if you are using DefaultSimilarity, shorter fields are boosted higher then longer fields in the Score calculation.
You can surely implement your own Simiarity class with a changed TF (Term Frequency) and LengthNorm Calculation as your needs.