why i am not getting the expected output? - c

int main()
{
int x;
float y;
char c;
x = -4443;
y = 24.25;
c = 'M';
printf("\nThe value of integer variable x is %f", (float)x);
printf("\nThe value of float variable y is %d", y);
printf("\nThe value of character variable c is %f\n",c);
return 0;
}
Output:
The value of integer variable x is -4443.000000
The value of float variable y is 0
The value of character variable c is 24.250000
Why am I not getting the expected output?
But when I am using external casting I am getting expected output which is:
The value of integer variable x is -4443.000000
The value of float variable y is 24
The value of character variable c is 77.000000

why i am not getting the expected output ?
Short answer: Because your expectations are wrong.
You're instructing the compiler to read an integer from where y is. Which is wrong. Format specifier don't tell the compiler to do casts, just what type to expect, and trust you to provide the right type.
The behaviour can be due to the fact that, for example, a float is stored in 8 bytes. The high-order bytes will be 0 in this case. But an int is stored in 4 bytes. So you tell the compiler read the int from where y is, it reads the first 4 bytes, which are 0, and prints 0...
EDIT: As John pointed out in the comments, this is UB, which means that anything can happen:
7.21.6.1/9
If a conversion specification is invalid, the behavior is undefined.282) If any argument is not the correct type for the corresponding conversion specification, the behavior is undefined.

Many computing platforms pass different types of arguments in different ways. On some platforms, floating-point arguments are passed in special floating-point registers. On most platforms, integer arguments are passed in general processor registers. Large arguments, such as structures, are stored somewhere in memory, and a pointer is passed instead (invisibly to the C source code). Once the few registers available for arguments are used, the remaining arguments are typically passed on the stack.
When you call printf, the compiler does not match the arguments you pass to the conversion specifiers in the format string. (Except that a good compiler will check and issue a warning if the types do not match.) In order to operate, the printf routine reads the format string and, when it finds a conversion specifier, it reads data from where the corresponding argument should be. If you specify “%d” but pass a float, the printf routine may read data from a general processor register, but the float value is in a floating-point register. Therefore, the value that is printed will be whatever data happened to be in the general processor register.
Similarly, when you specify “%f” but pass an integer, the printf routine may read from a floating-point register, but the integer value is in a general processor register.
The compiler will not convert printf arguments to the target type and might not warn you about the mismatches. You must match the conversion specifiers in the format string to the argument types.
Bonus: Here are documents describing how arguments are passed to subroutines on one platform (Mac OS X).

You cannot format a char as a float "%f", use "%c" or "%d" instead. I find that http://www.cplusplus.com/reference/clibrary/cstdio/printf/ is a good reference.

The format specifiers and the types of the arguments don't match, which I believe causes undefined behavior. printf doesn't do casting for you, so you have to explicitly cast the arguments.

Related

Do format specifiers perform implicit type conversion?

#include <stdio.h>
int main(void) {
int x = 5;
int y = &x;
printf("Signed Value of Y: %d \n", y);
printf("Unsigned Value of Y: %u", y);
return 0;
}
Since y is of int type, using %d gives a possibly-signed output, whereas %u gives an unsigned output. But y is of int type, so why does %u give unsigned output? Is there an implicit type conversion?
"Re: But y is of int type, So why does %u give unsigned output?"
From C11:
If a conversion specification is invalid, the behavior is
undefined. If any argument is not the correct type for the
corresponding conversion specification, the behavior is undefined.
where,
undefined — The behavior for something incorrect, on which the
standard does not impose any requirements. Anything is allowed to
happen, from nothing, to a warning message to program termination, to
CPU meltdown, to launching nuclear missiles (assuming you have the
correct hardware option installed).
— Expert C Programming.
Effectively, a printf call is two separate things:
All the arguments are prepared to send to the function.
The function interprets the format string and its other arguments.
In any function call, the arguments are prepared according to rules involving the argument types and the function declaration. They do not depend on the values of the arguments, including the contents of any string passed as an argument, and this is true of printf too.
In a function call, the rules are largely (omitting some details):
If the argument corresponds to a declared parameter type, it is converted to that type.
Otherwise (if the argument corresponds to the ... part of a function declaration or the called function is declared without specifying parameter types), some default promotions are applied. For integers, these are the integer promotions, which largely (omitting some details) convert types narrower than int to int. For floating-point, float is promoted to double.
printf is declared as int printf(const char * restrict format, ...);, so all its arguments other than the format string correspond to ....
Inside printf, the function examines its format string and attempts to perform the directives given in the format string. For example, if a directive is %g, printf expects a double argument and takes bits from the place it expects a double argument to be passed. Then it interprets those bits as a double, constructs a string according to the directive, and writes the string to standard output.
For a %d or %u directive, printf expects an int or an unsigned int argument, respectively. In either case, it takes bits from the place it expects an int or an unsigned int argument to be passed. In all C implementations I am aware of, an int and an unsigned int argument are passed in the same place. So, if you pass an int argument but use %u, printf will get the bits of an int but will treat them as if they were the bits of an unsigned int. No actual conversion has been performed; printf is merely interpreting the bits differently.
The C standard does not define the behavior when you do this, and a C implementation would be conforming to the standard if it crashed when you did this or if it processed the bits differently. You should avoid it.
Is there an implicit type conversion?
Sort of. A function such as printf that accepts a variable number of arguments does not automatically know the number of variable arguments it actually receives on any call, or their types. Conversion specifications such as %d and %u collectively tell printf() how many variable arguments to expect, and individually they tell printf what type to expect for each argument. printf() will try to interpret the argument list according to these specifications.
The C language specification explicitly declines to say what happens when the types of printf arguments do not correspond properly to the conversion specifications in the accompanying format string. In practice, however, some pairs of data types have representations similar enough to each other that printf()'s attempt to interpret data of one type as if it were the other type is likely (but not guaranteed) to give the appearance of an implicit conversion from one type to the other. Corresponding signed and unsigned integer types are typically such pairs.
You should not rely on such apparent conversions actually happening. Instead, properly match argument types with conversion specifications. Correct mismatches by choosing a different conversion specification or performing an appropriate explicit type conversion (a typecast) on the argument.

Why is this code printing 0?

void main()
{
clrscr();
float f = 3.3;
/* In printf() I intentionaly put %d format specifier to see
what type of output I may get */
printf("value of variable a is: %d", f);
getch();
}
In effect, %d tells printf to look in a certain place for an integer argument. But you passed a float argument, which is put in a different place. The C standard does not specify what happens when you do this. In this case, it may be there was a zero in the place printf looked for an integer argument, so it printed “0”. In other circumstances, something different may happen.
Using an invalid format specifier to printf invokes undefined behavior. This is specified in section 7.21.6.1p9 of the C standard:
If a conversion specification is invalid, the behavior is
undefined.282) If any argument is not the correct type for the
corresponding conversion specification, the behavior is undefined.
What this means is that you can't reliably predict what the output of the program will be. For example, the same code on my system prints -1554224520 as the value.
As to what's most likely happening, the %d format specifier is looking for an int as a parameter. Assuming that an int is passed on the stack and that an int is 4 bytes long, the printf function looks at the next 4 bytes on the stack for the value given. Many implementations don't pass floating point values on the stack but in registers instead, so it instead sees whatever garbage values happen to be there. Even if a float is passed on the stack, a float and an int have very different representations, so printing the bytes of a float as an int will most likely not give you the same value.
Let's look at a different example for a moment. Suppose I write
#include <string.h>
char buf[10];
float f = 3.3;
memset(buf, 'x', f);
The third argument to memset is supposed to be an integer (actually a value of type size_t) telling memset how many characters of buf to set to 'x'. But I passed a float value instead. What happens? Well, the compiler knows that the third argument is supposed to be an integer, so it automatically performs the appropriate conversion, and the code ends up setting the first three (three point zero) characters of buf to 'x'.
(Significantly, the way the compiler knew that the third argument of memset was supposed to be an integer was based on the prototype function declaration for memset which is part of the header <string.h>.)
Now, when you called
printf("value of variable f is: %d", f);
you might think the same thing happens. You passed a float, but %d expects an int, so an automatic conversion will happen, right?
Wrong. Let me say that again: Wrong.
The perhaps surprising fact is, printf is different. printf is special. The compiler can't necessarily know what the right types of the arguments passed to printf are supposed to be, because it depends on the details of the %-specifiers buried in the format string. So there are no automatic conversions to just the right type. It's your job to make sure that the types of the arguments you actually pass are exactly right for the format specifiers. If they don't match, the compiler does not automatically perform corresponding conversions. If they don't match, what happens is that you get crazy, wrong results.
(What does the prototype function declaration for printf look like? It literally looks like this: extern int printf(const char *, ...);. Those three dots ... indicate a variable-length argument list or "varargs", they tell the compiler it can't know how many more arguments there are, or what their types are supposed to be. So the compiler performs a few basic conversions -- such as upconverting types char and short int to int, and float to double -- and leaves it at that.)
I said "The compiler can't necessarily know what the right types of the arguments passed to printf are supposed to be", but these days, good compilers go the extra mile and try to figure it out anyway, if they can. They still won't perform automatic conversions (they're not really allowed to, by the rules of the language), but they can at least warn you. For example, I tried your code under two different compilers. Both said something along the lines of warning: format specifies type 'int' but the argument has type 'float'. If your compiler isn't giving you warnings like these, I encourage you to find out if those warnings can be enabled, or consider switching to a better compiler.
Try
printf("... %f",f);
That's how you print float numbers.
Maybe you only want to print x digits of f, eg.:
printf("... %.3f" f);
That will print your float number with 3 digits after the dot.
Please read through this list:
%c - Character
%d or %i - Signed decimal integer
%e - Scientific notation (mantissa/exponent) using e character
%E - Scientific notation (mantissa/exponent) using E character
%f - Decimal floating point
%g - Uses the shorter of %e or %f
%G - Uses the shorter of %E or %f
%o - Signed octal
%s - String of characters
%u - Unsigned decimal integer
%x - Unsigned hexadecimal integer
%X - Unsigned hexadecimal integer (capital letters)
%p - Pointer address
%n - Nothing printed
The code is printing a 0, because you are using the format tag %d, which represents Signed decimal integer (http://devdocs.io).
Could you please try
void main() {
clrscr();
float f=3.3;
/* In printf() I intentionaly put %d format specifier to see what type of output I may get */
printf("value of variable a is: %f",f);
getch();
}

why printf behaves differently when we try to print float as a hexadecimal? [duplicate]

I tried to print character as a float in printf and got output 0. What is the reason for this.
Also:
char c='z';
printf("%f %X",c,c);
is giving some weird output for hexadecimal while output is correct when I do this:
printf("%X",c);
why is it so?
The printf() function is a variadic function, which means that you can pass a variable number of arguments of unspecified types to it. This also means that the compiler doesn't know what type of arguments the function expects, and so it cannot convert the arguments to the correct types. (Modern compilers can warn you if you get the arguments wrong to printf, if you invoke it with enough warning flags.)
For historical reasons, you can not pass an integer argument of smaller rank than int, or a floating type of smaller rank than double to a variadic function. A float will be converted to double and a char will be converted to int (or unsigned int on bizarre implementations) through a process called the default argument promotions.
When printf parses its parameters (arguments are passed to a function, parameters are what the function receives), it retrieves them using whatever method is appropriate for the type specified by the format string. The "%f" specifier expects a double. The "%X" specifier expects an unsigned int.
If you pass an int and printf tries to retrieve a double, you invoke undefined behaviour.
If you pass an int and printf tries to retrieve an unsigned int, you invoke undefined behaviour.
Undefined behaviour may include (but is not limited to) printing strange values, crashing your program or (the most insidious of them all) doing exactly what you expect.
Source: n1570 (The final public draft of the current C standard)
You need to use a cast operator like this:
char c = 'z';
printf("%f %X", (float)c, c);
or
printf("%f %X", (double)c, c);
In Xcode, if I do not do this, I get the warning:
Format specifies specifies 'double' but the argument has type 'char', and the output is 0.000000.
I tried to print character as a float in printf and got output 0. What is the reason for this.
The question is, what value did you expect to see? Why would you expect something other than 0?
The short answer to your question is that the behavior of printf is undefined if the type of the argument doesn't match the conversion specifier. The %f conversion specifier expects its corresponding argument to have type double; if it isn't, all bets are off, and the exact output will vary.
To understand the floating point issue, consider reading: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/IEEE_floating_point
As for hexadecimal, let me guess.. the output was something like... 99?
This is because of encodings.. the machine has to represent information in some format, and usually that format entails either giving meanings to certain bits in a number, or having a table of symbols to numbers, or both
Floating points are sometimes represented as a (sign,mantissa,exponent) triplet all packed in a 32 or 64 bit number - characters are sometimes represented in a format named ASCII, which establishes which number corresponds to each character you type
Because printf, like any function that work with varargs, eg: int foobar(const char fmt, ...) {} tries to interpret its parameter to certain type.
If you say "%f", then pass c (as a char), then printf will try to read a float.
You can read more here: var_arg (even if this is C++, it still applies).

why printf behaves differently when we try to print character as a float and as a hexadecimal?

I tried to print character as a float in printf and got output 0. What is the reason for this.
Also:
char c='z';
printf("%f %X",c,c);
is giving some weird output for hexadecimal while output is correct when I do this:
printf("%X",c);
why is it so?
The printf() function is a variadic function, which means that you can pass a variable number of arguments of unspecified types to it. This also means that the compiler doesn't know what type of arguments the function expects, and so it cannot convert the arguments to the correct types. (Modern compilers can warn you if you get the arguments wrong to printf, if you invoke it with enough warning flags.)
For historical reasons, you can not pass an integer argument of smaller rank than int, or a floating type of smaller rank than double to a variadic function. A float will be converted to double and a char will be converted to int (or unsigned int on bizarre implementations) through a process called the default argument promotions.
When printf parses its parameters (arguments are passed to a function, parameters are what the function receives), it retrieves them using whatever method is appropriate for the type specified by the format string. The "%f" specifier expects a double. The "%X" specifier expects an unsigned int.
If you pass an int and printf tries to retrieve a double, you invoke undefined behaviour.
If you pass an int and printf tries to retrieve an unsigned int, you invoke undefined behaviour.
Undefined behaviour may include (but is not limited to) printing strange values, crashing your program or (the most insidious of them all) doing exactly what you expect.
Source: n1570 (The final public draft of the current C standard)
You need to use a cast operator like this:
char c = 'z';
printf("%f %X", (float)c, c);
or
printf("%f %X", (double)c, c);
In Xcode, if I do not do this, I get the warning:
Format specifies specifies 'double' but the argument has type 'char', and the output is 0.000000.
I tried to print character as a float in printf and got output 0. What is the reason for this.
The question is, what value did you expect to see? Why would you expect something other than 0?
The short answer to your question is that the behavior of printf is undefined if the type of the argument doesn't match the conversion specifier. The %f conversion specifier expects its corresponding argument to have type double; if it isn't, all bets are off, and the exact output will vary.
To understand the floating point issue, consider reading: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/IEEE_floating_point
As for hexadecimal, let me guess.. the output was something like... 99?
This is because of encodings.. the machine has to represent information in some format, and usually that format entails either giving meanings to certain bits in a number, or having a table of symbols to numbers, or both
Floating points are sometimes represented as a (sign,mantissa,exponent) triplet all packed in a 32 or 64 bit number - characters are sometimes represented in a format named ASCII, which establishes which number corresponds to each character you type
Because printf, like any function that work with varargs, eg: int foobar(const char fmt, ...) {} tries to interpret its parameter to certain type.
If you say "%f", then pass c (as a char), then printf will try to read a float.
You can read more here: var_arg (even if this is C++, it still applies).

Puzzled about printf output

While using printf with %d as format specifier and giving a float as an argument e.g, 2.345, it prints 1546188227. So, I understand that it may be due to the conversion of single point float precision format to simple decimal format. But when we print 2.000 with the %d as format specifier, then why it prints 0 only ?
Please help.
Format specifier %d can only be used with values of type int (and compatible types). Trying to use %d with float or any other types produces undefined behavior. That's the only explanation that truly applies here. From the language point of view the output you see is essentially random. And you are not guaranteed to get any output at all.
If you are still interested in investigating the specific reason for the output you see (however little sense it makes), you'll have to perform a platform-specific investigation, because the actual behavior depends critically on various implementation details. And you are not even mentioning your platform in your post.
In any case, as a side note, note that it is impossible to pass float values as variadic arguments to variadic functions. float values in such cases are always converted to double and passed as double. So in your case it is double values you are attempting to print. Behavior is still undefined though.
Go here, enter 2.345, click "rounded". Observe 64-bit hex value: 4002C28F5C28F5C3. Observe that 1546188227 is 0x5c28f5c3.
Now repeat for 2.00. Observe that 64-bit hex value is 4000000000000000
P.S. When you say that you give a float argument, what you apparently mean is that you give a double argument.
Here what ISO/IEC 9899:1999 standard $7.19.6 states:
If a conversion specification is invalid, the behavior is undefined.239)
If any argument is not the correct type for the corresponding conversion
specification, the behavior is undefined.
If you're trying to make it print integer values, cast the floats to ints in the call:
printf("ints: %d %d", (int) 2.345, (int) 2.000);
Otherwise, use the floating point format identifier:
printf("floats: %f %f", 2.345, 2.000);
When you use printf with wrong format specifier for the corresponding argument, the result is undefined behavior. It could be anything and may differ from one implementation to another. Only correct use of format specified has defined behavior.
First a small nitpick: The literal 2.345 is actually of the type double, not float, and besides, even a float, such as the literal 2.345f, would be converted to double when used as an argument to a function that takes a variable number of arguments, such as printf.
But what happens here is that the (typically) 64 bits of the double value is sent to printf, and then it interprets (typically) 32 of those bits as an integer value. So it just happens that those bits were zero.
According to the standard, this is what is called undefined behavior: The compiler is allowed to do anything at all.

Resources