I have some doubt on below code
#include<stdio.h>
int i=6;
int main()
{
int i=4;
{
extern int i;
printf("%d",i); //prints 6
}
printf("%d",i); //prints 4
}
we know that extern keyword says compiler, the variable is somewhere outside. So the question is why the extern keyword is accessing the global i variable but not the i variable which is within the main function? I was thinking there must be a contradiction because both variables are available to the inner braces as global variable. So does extern keyword access the variable which is outside the function or does it also access the variable which is outside the braces.
extern doesn't mean outside the current scope, it means an object with external linkage. An automatic variable never has external linkage, so your declaration extern int i can't possibly refer to that. Hence it's hiding it, the same as the automatic variable hid the global.
Before the printf that prints 6 you are asking the compiler to use the i defined after the #include. The closing brace then tells the compiler that the extern is no longer in effect, therefore it uses the scope where i is set to 4.
int i=4 is not global variable, if you try to access var i which is inside main in another function your compiler will thrown error about var i is undeclared. This code illustrates it.
void func() {
printf("i is %d\n",i);
}
main() {
int i=10;
func();
}
Whereas the i outside of main is global variable, which you can access in all functions.
I think you're asking whether you're right in thinking that the extern int i declaration should cause the first printf to resolve i to 4 because that int i=4 statement is in a parent scope of the scope in which the extern is declared.
The answer is no, hence the behaviour you're seeing. An extern declaration within a function is used to declare the existence of an external variable and won't ever resolve to a local variable (a variable declared within the function).
/* what Ed Heal said */
Yet, I think it would be best to illustrate it with additional example. I modified Your example to do a little more. The comments in the code tells the most of it:
#include <stdio.h>
int i = 6;
int main(void)
{
int i = 4;
printf("%d\n", i); /* prints 4 */
{
extern int i; /* this i is now "current". */
printf("%d\n", i); /* prints 6 */
{
int *x = &i; /* Save the address of the "old" i,
* before making a new one. */
int i = 32; /* one more i. Becomes the "current" i.*/
printf("%d\n", i); /* prints 32 */
printf("%d\n", *x); /* prints 6 - "old" i through a pointer.*/
}
/* The "previous" i goes out of scope.
* That extern one is "current" again. */
printf("%d\n", i); /* prints 6 again */
}
/* That extern i goes out of scope.
* The only remaining i is now "current". */
printf("%d\n", i); /* prints 4 again */
return 0;
}
Related
I had this assignment at school, wherein I had to find the output of the following C code, and also, to explain the output.
#include<stdio.h>
int i;
void fun1(void);
void fun2(void);
int main()
{
fun1();
fun2();
return 0;
}
void fun1(){
i=20;
printf("%d\t",i);
}
void fun2(){
int i=50;
printf("%d",i);
}
The output is 20 50
Because in fun1() the Global Variable 'i' is assigned to 20 and printed. And in fun2() the variable 'i' is a Local Variable, which is declared and initialized to 50, which is then printed.
I have this following question out of curiosity, how do I use the global variable 'i', in fun2()?
A simple solution would be to simply change the name and avoid the whole thing. But my curiosity is due to Java, where there is a keyword "this" to access class variable instead of a local variable.
so is there any way to do that in C?
The only way is to hide the declaration of the local variable in a code block.
For example
#include <stdio.h>
int i = 10;
void fun2( void )
{
int i = 20;
printf("local i = %d\n",i);
{
extern int i;
printf( "global i = %d\n",i);
}
}
int main(void)
{
fun2();
}
The program output is
local i = 20
global i = 10
There is no way to access a global parameter inside a function that has a local variable with the same name. It is usually bad practice to create such local variables in C though, as you saw, it is not prohibited.
In C++ you can solve it using namespaces but there is no equivalent in C.
The best way is to pass parameters to the function
void fun2(int fromExternalWorld){
int i=50;
printf("%d ",fromExternalWorld);
printf("%d\n",i);
}
int main(void)
{
fun2(i);
}
Otherwise is not possible to have two symbols with same name visible in the same scope.
You could cheat and create a pointer to the global i before declaring the local i:
void fun2( void )
{
int *ip = &i; // get address of global i
int i = 50; // local i ”shadows" global i
printf( "local i = %d, global i = %d\n", i, *ip );
}
EDIT
Seeing as this answer got accepted, I must emphasize that you should never write code like this. This is a band-aid around poor programming practice.
Avoid globals where possible, and where not possible use a naming convention that clearly marks them as global and is unlikely to be shadowed (such as prefixing with a g_ or something similar).
I can't tell you how many hours I've wasted chasing down issues that were due to a naming collision like this.
See the comments to see what is being referred as declaration.
If the whole variable declaration part was missing, what would be the problem?
Appears that variable definition and initialization either simultaneously or separately like in the example would suffice.
#include <stdio.h>
// Variable declaration:
extern int a, b;
extern int c;
extern float f;
int main () {
/* variable definition: */
int a, b;
int c;
float f;
/* actual initialization */
a = 10;
b = 20;
c = a + b;
printf("value of c : %d \n", c);
f = 70.0/3.0;
printf("value of f : %f \n", f);
return 0;
}
If the declaration was missing then it would create no problem in main function since the locally defined variables i.e. a,b,c,f will be used in the functionality of main till its scope ends.
The declaration merely tells that the definition lies elsewhere (in some other .c file) or the definition lies after the function main in the same .c file.
There will be no problem here if the mentioned declaration is missing.
// Variable declaration:
extern int a, b;
extern int c;
extern float f;
This tells the compiler that these variables are defined somewhere else(in another file).
/* variable definition: */
int a, b;
int c;
float f;
This is where you define variables but they are not the same as the external variables you declared since they are in the inner scope of the main function.
The scope is the place where variables live. extern keyword notes that the scope is global.
You can define variables with the same name in an inner scope and access only them as you did in the main function but it's not a good practice.
void foo()
{
int a = 5;
printf("%d\n", a); // 5
// Creating an inner scope
{
int a = 20;
printf("%d\n", a); // 20
}
printf("%d\n", a); // 5
}
The correct way to use the extern keyword with variables is like this.
//h1.h
extern int global_var; // Declaration of the variable
//c1.c
#include h1.h
int global_var = 0; // Definition of the global var. Memory is allocated here.
//main.c
#include h1.h
int main()
{
printf("global var value is %d\n", global_var); // use of the var defined and
// initialized in c1.c
return 0;
}
This program will print 0 since the variable is defined and initialized in c1.c.
Extern extends the visibility of the C variables and C functions. so that lets the compiler know that there is another place that those vars are declared and memory was allocated for them elsewhere.
for example in another c file.
if you compile a c file containing a global var for example:
int c = 5;
and you create a function on you c file that uses this c var, for example:
int someFunc(void){
return c;}
if you run someFunc in your main and print its return value, you will get 5. but you must compile both c files together.
in your program, you only use the locally allocated var declared in your main function.
When it comes to simple variables, there is really no difference between the declaration and definition. There is a difference when it comes to structs and functions. Here is an example:
// Declarations
struct myStruct;
int foo();
int main()
{
...
}
// Definitions
struct myStruct {
int a, b;
};
int foo() {
return 42;
}
In your case, you are hiding the previous declarations so that they are not accessible before the end of the scope. This is commonly called shadowing. It's basically the same thing as this:
int main()
{
int i=0;
printf("i: %d\n", i);
{
int i=42; // Now the previous i is inaccessible within this scope
printf("i: %d\n", i);
}
// And now it is accessible again
printf("i: %d\n", i);
}
I am learning how to use a extern variable, I wrote a simple program to try it but it doesnt seem to be working. I've looked at some examples but I don't know whats wrong.
Here is my code:
globals.h
#ifndef GLOBALS_H_
#define GLOBALS_H_
extern int gval;
#endif /* GLOBALS_H_ */
main.c
#include <stdio.h>
#include "globals.h"
int main() {
int gval = 4;
printf("1st value is: %i", gval);
printf("2nd value is: %i", modded());
}
modify.c
#include "globals.h"
int modded() {
return gval++;
}
The error seems to be that gval is undefined in modify.c, but I don't get how.
As it stands, you've declared a global variable gval in the header, and you've hidden that global declaration with a locally defined variable gval in the main() function. This is legal, but only sometimes (I'm tempted to say 'occasionally' or 'seldom') what is intended. If you use GCC, using the -Wshadow option would warn you about shadowing variables like that. It is generally a bad idea to shadow global variables.
The simplest fix to your code is to move the definition of gval outside main():
#include <stdio.h>
#include "globals.h"
int gval = 4;
int main(void)
{
printf("1st value is: %i", gval);
printf("2nd value is: %i", modded());
return 0;
}
However, you should note that although it will compile and run, the second value printed will be the same as the first because modded() returns the unmodified version of the value. To see the effect, you need:
#include "globals.h"
int modded(void)
{
return ++gval;
}
Were it my code, there'd be a declaration of modded() in globals.h. You should not be calling a function without a prototype in scope according to C99 and C11 (the old and current C standard). Of necessity, the original C89 standard was more lax about that rule; it had to be to accommodate the pre-existing non-standard code. However, for code written in the 21st Century, there's no real excuse for not having a prototype in scope before you use a function.
A global extern variable must be defined somewhere, but in your code, the gval in main is a local variable, there's no definition of the global variable. This line
extern int gval;
is a declaration, not a definition. In other words, you must have
int gval;
somewhere outside all functions.
Even if a global gval were defined, note that the global gval is invisible in the scope of local gval
Change your main.c to
#include <stdio.h>
#include "globals.h"
int gval; // define (allocate space for) the global variable
int main(void) {
// int gval = 4; -- wrong -- this defines and initializes a local variable that hides the global of the same name
gval = 4; // use the global variable, assigning to it ... or you could initialize it at the definition above and omit this line
printf("1st value is: %i", gval);
printf("2nd value is: %i", modded());
}
and change modded to
int modded(void) {
// return gval++; -- wrong -- this is postfix increment and returns the value *before* incrementing
return ++gval; // use prefix increment
}
You also should have a modify.h that contains the prototype for modded that you include in main.c, or just put modded inside main.c before main.
Another approach is to change modded to not return a value, since it is changing a global, thus:
void modgval(void) {
++gval; // or gval++
}
And then in main:
printf("1st value is: %i", gval);
modgval();
printf("2nd value is: %i", gval);
Just put Gval before the main declaration and you're ready to go ;)
This is a simple example describing how to share a variable between source files:
File 1:
int GlobalVariable; // explicit definition, this actually allocates as well as describing
void SomeFunction(void); // function prototype (declaration), assumes defined elsewhere, normally from include file.
int main() {
GlobalVariable = 1;
SomeFunction();
return 0;
}
File 2:
extern int GlobalVariable; // implicit declaration, this only describes and assumes allocated elsewhere, normally from include
void SomeFunction(void) { // function header (definition)
++GlobalVariable;
}
In this example, the variable GlobalVariable is defined in File 1. In order to utilize the same variable in File 2, it must be declared. Regardless of the number of files, a global variable is only defined once, however, it must be declared in any file outside of the one containing the definition.
In your case gval in main is a local variable, instead define a global variable and then use extern to share variable in different source files.
Can anyone please tell me is there any special requirement to use either EXTERN or GLOBAL variables in a C program?
I do not see any difference in a program like below, if I change from gloabl to extern.
#include <stdio.h>
#include <stdlib.h>
int myGlobalvar = 10;
int main(int argc, char *argv[])
{
int myFunc(int);
int i;
i = 12;
myGlobalvar = 100;
printf("Value of myGlobalvar is %d , i = %d\n", myGlobalvar, i);
i = myFunc(10);
printf("Value of passed value : %d\n",i);
printf("again Value of myGlobalvar is %d , i = %d\n", myGlobalvar, i);
system("PAUSE");
return 0;
}
int myFunc(int i)
{
i = 20 + 1000;
//extern int myGlobalvar;
myGlobalvar = 20000;
// printf("Value of passed value : %d",i);
return i;
}
If uncomment extern int myGlobalvar, the value does not change.
Is there any correct difference between both?
Can anyone please correct me?
The keyword extern means "the storage for this variable is allocated elsewhere". It tells the compiler "I'm referencing myGlobalvar here, and you haven't seen it before, but that's OK; the linker will know what you are talking about." In your specific example it's not particularly useful, because the compiler does know about myGlobalvar -- it's defined earlier in the same translation unit (.c or .cc file.) You normally use extern when you want to refer to something that is not in the current translation unit, such as a variable that's defined in a library you will be linking to.
(Of course, normally that library would declare the extern variables for you, in a header file that you should include.)
From Here:
A global variable in C/C++ is a variable which can be accessed from any module in your program.
int myGlobalVariable;
This allocates storage for the data, and tells the compiler that you want to access that storage with the name 'myGlobalVariable'.
But what do you do if you want to access that variable from another module in the program? You can't use the same statement given above, because then you'll have 2 variables named 'myGlobalVariable', and that's not allowed. So, the solution is to let your other modules DECLARE the variable without DEFINING it:
extern int myGlobalVariable;
This tells the compiler "there's a variable defined in another module called myGlobalVariable, of type integer. I want you to accept my attempts to access it, but don't allocate storage for it because another module has already done that".
Since myGlobalvar has been defined before the function myFunc. Its declaration inside the function is redundant.
But if the definition was after the function, we must have the declaration.
int myFunc(int i)
{
i = 20 + 1000;
extern int myGlobalvar; // Declaration must now.
myGlobalvar = 20000;
printf("Value of passed value : %d",i);
return i;
}
int myGlobalvar = 10; // Def after the function.
In short: GLOBAL variables are declared in one file. But they can be accessed in another file only with the EXTERN word before (in this another file). In the same file, no need of EXTERN.
for example:
my_file.cpp
int global_var = 3;
int main(){
}
You can access the global variable in the same file. No need to use EXTERN:
my_file.cpp
int global_var = 3;
int main(){
++global_var;
std::cout << global_var; // Displays '4'
}
Global variable, by definition, can also be accessed by all the other files.
BUT, in this case, you need to access the global variable using EXTERN.
So, with my_file.cpp declaring the global_var, in other_file.cpp if you try this:
other_file.cpp
int main(){
++global_var; // ERROR!!! Compiler is complaining of a 'non-declared' variable
std::cout << global_var;
}
Instead, do:
int main(){
extern int global_var;//Note: 'int global_var' without 'extern' would
// simply create a separate different variable
++global_var; // and '++global_var' wouldn't work since it'll
// complain that the variable was not initiazed.
std::cout << global_var; // WORKING: it shows '4'
}
myGlobalVar as you've defined it is a global variable, visible from all the places in your program. There's no need declaring it extern in the same .c file . That is useful for other .c files to let the compiler know this variable is going to be used.
How can I access a shadowed global variable in C? In C++ I can use :: for the global namespace.
If your file-scope variable is not static, then you can use a declaration that uses extern in a nested scope:
int c;
int main() {
{
int c = 0;
// now, c shadows ::c. just re-declare ::c in a
// nested scope:
{
extern int c;
c = 1;
}
// outputs 0
printf("%d\n", c);
}
// outputs 1
printf("%d\n", c);
return 0;
}
If the variable is declared with static, i don't see a way to refer to it.
There is no :: in c but you can use a getter function
#include <stdio.h>
int L=3;
inline int getL()
{
return L;
}
int main();
{
int L = 5;
printf("%d, %d", L, getL());
}
If you are talking about shadowed global var, then (on Linux) you can use dlsym() to find an address of the global variable, like this:
int myvar = 5; // global
{
int myvar = 6; // local var shadows global
int *pglob_myvar = (int *)dlsym(RTLD_NEXT, "myvar");
printf("Local: %d, global: %d\n", myvar, *pglob_myvar);
}
If you want your code to look sexy, use macro:
#define GLOBAL_ADDR(a,b) b =(typeof(b))dlsym(RTLD_NEXT, #a)
...
int *pglob_myvar;
GLOBAL_ADDR(myvar, pglob_myvar);
...
Depending on what you call shielded global variable in C, different answers are possible.
If you mean a global variable defined in another source file or a linked library, you only have to declare it again with the extern prefix:
extern int aGlobalDefinedElsewhere;
If you mean a global variable shadowed (or eclipsed, choose the terminology you prefer) by a local variable of the same name), there is no builtin way to do this in C. So you have either not to do it or to work around it. Possible solutions are:
getter/setter functions for accessing global variable (which is a good practice, in particular in multithreaded situations)
aliases to globals by way of a pointer defined before the local variable:
int noName;
{
int * aliasToNoName = &noName; /* reference to global */
int noName; /* declaration of local */
*aliasToNoName = noName; /* assign local to global */
}
what is a "shielded global variable" in pure C?
in C you have local variables, file local/global variables (static) and global variables (extern)
so file1.c:
int bla;
file2.c
extern int bla;
Yet another option is to reference the global before defining your local, or at least get a pointer to it first so you can access it after defining your local.
#include <stdio.h>
int x = 1234;
int main()
{
printf("%d\n",x); // prints global
int x = 456;
printf("%d\n",x); // prints local
}