Silverlight HttpWebRequest.Create hangs inside async block - silverlight

Question

I am trying to prototype a Rpc Call to a JBOSS webserver from Silverlight (4). I have written the code and it is working in a console application - so I know that Jboss is responding to the web request. Porting it to silverlight 4, is causing issues:
let uri = new Uri(queryUrl)
// this is the line that hangs
let request : HttpWebRequest = downcast WebRequest.Create(uri)
request.Method <- httpMethod;
request.ContentType <- contentType
It may be a sandbox issue, as my silverlight is being served off of my file system and the Uri is a reference to the localhost - though I am not even getting an exception. Thoughts?
Thx
UPDATE 1
I created a new project and ported my code over and now it is working; something must be unstable w/ regard to the F# Silverlight integration still. Still would appreciate thoughts on debugging the "hanging" web create in the old model...
UPDATE 2
let uri = Uri("http://localhost./portal/main?isSecure=IbongAdarnaNiFranciscoBalagtas")
// this WebRequest.Create works fine
let req : HttpWebRequest = downcast WebRequest.Create(uri)
let Login = async {
let uri = new Uri("http://localhost/portal/main?isSecure=IbongAdarnaNiFranciscoBalagtas")
// code hangs on this WebRequest.Create
let request : HttpWebRequest = downcast WebRequest.Create(uri)
return request
}
Login |> Async.RunSynchronously
I must be missing something; the Async block works fine in the console app - is it not allowed in the Silverlight App?

Answer 1

(Thanks for sending this to fsbugs, to force us to take a hard look.)
The problem is Async.RunSynchronously. When called on the UI thread, this blocks the UI thread. And it turns out that WebRequest.Create() on Silverlight dispatches to the UI thread. So it is a deadlock.
In general, try to avoid Async.RunSynchronously on Silverlight (or on any UI thread). You can use Async.StartImmediate in this example. Alternatively, I think you can call RunSynchronously from any background thread without issues. (I have not tried enough end-to-end Silverlight scenarios myself to offer more advice as yet. You might check out
Game programming in F# (with Silverlight and WPF)
F# and Silverlight
F# async on the client side
for a few short examples.)
(In retrospect, the F# design team thinks that we maybe should not have included Async.RunSynchronously in FSharp.Core for Silverlight; the method potentially violates the spirit of the platform (no blocking calls). It's possible we'll deprecate that method in future Silverlight releases. On the other hand, it still does have valid uses for CPU-intensive parallelism on Silverlight, e.g. running a bunch on (non-IO) code in parallel on background threads.)

Answer 2

Seems like a similar issue here - though no reference to silverlight (in fact it is a "windows service class"):
http://social.msdn.microsoft.com/Forums/en-US/netfxnetcom/thread/10854fc4-2149-41e2-b315-c533586bb65d

Answer 3

I had similar problem. I was making a Silverlight MVVM ViewModel to bind data from web.
Don Syme commented himself:
I’m not a data-binding expert, but I
believe you can’t “hide” the asyncness
of a view model like this for WPF and
Silverlight. I think you would need to
expose Task, Async or an
observable collection. AFAIK the only
way to get Silverlight and WPF to bind
asynchronously to a property is if it
is an observable collection.
Anyway, I installed F# Power Pack to get AsyncReadToEnd.
It didn't solve the case... I added domains to trusted sites but it didn't help... Then I added a MySolution.Web -asp.net-site and clientaccesspolicy.xml. I don't know if those had any effect.
Now, with Async.StartImmediate I got web service call working:
let mutable callresult = ""
//let event = new Event<string>()
//let eventvalue = event.Publish
let internal fetch (url : Uri) trigger =
let req = WebRequest.CreateHttp url
//req.CookieContainer <- new CookieContainer()
let asynccall =
async{
try
let! res = req.AsyncGetResponse()
use stream = res.GetResponseStream()
use reader = new StreamReader(stream)
let! txt = reader.AsyncReadToEnd()
//event.Trigger(txt)
callresult <- txt //I had some processing here...
trigger "" |> ignore
with
| :? System.Exception as ex ->
failwith(ex.ToString()) //just for debug
}
asynccall |> Async.StartImmediate
Now I will need my ViewModel to listen the mutable callresult.
In your case you need also a crossdomain.xml to the server.
The trigger is needed to use the UI-thread:
let trigger _ =
let update _ = x.myViewModelProperty <- callresult
System.Windows.Deployment.Current.Dispatcher.BeginInvoke(new Action(update)) |> ignore
fetch serviceUrl trigger

Answer 4

I think you are hitting the maximum http connections restriction: see Aynchronous web server calls in Silverlight and maximum HTTP connections and http://weblogs.asp.net/mschwarz/archive/2008/07/21/internet-explorer-8-and-maximum-concurrent-connections.aspx